News
Video: IDF officer headbutts Palestinian teen
Yoav Zitun
Published: 26.07.12, 19:11
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
100 Talkbacks for this article
61. I made a posting error. Under #9's comment
Reuven   (07.27.12)
I pressed the wrong prompt and ended up recommending what the poster (the anti-Israel, Split) wrote. I had meant to reply to his nasty post. I don't want to recommend anything written by an anti-Israel (& anti-Semitic) creep. Please, please delete my recommendation for #9. Todah Rabah, Reuven.
62. @52. Provide the link.!
PETER SM ,   MELBOURNE AUSTRALIA   (07.27.12)
63. #7: btselem arent traitors
david ,   new york   (07.27.12)
they are arabs
64. Most respected army
Edouard ,   Canada Montreal   (07.27.12)
I hope that this officer will get a medal for not killing this guy This Arab teens are trying their best to become a shaaid They're not afraid because we are to nice Or the obei or the get shot this should be the only policy
65. Cameramen Soldiers
Chris White ,   London, UK   (07.27.12)
Stop allowing non-military cameramen into some operational zones, make this a priority, like in Iraq/ US/Afghan arena, rarely do we see operational footage. the reason is twofold, one, because war is ugly and most ppl would rather not have to see it and two, as in this case and most b tselem videos the footage is taken out of context, re-edited, and made into a clip that looks particularly viscious when in fact its a very common thing to see this kind of violence in context, and even more violence like shooting, bombing, knifing, stoning--this is reality of war, however sad. Its also pretty damn scary walking down those streets in a uniform when every one is looking at you and wants to grind you into a bit of chop meat, one develops a tough skin, and remains in high alert, ready for battle. There should be limited camera use by non military personel and more camera use by the IDF itself, to show its side.
66. Go IDF!!!
Jake Stone ,   USA   (07.27.12)
Be assured this punk Palestinian deserved what he got! The Pals' are always starting trouble. This video is a joke!
67. Part of the story only.
SD Charger ,   San Diego   (07.27.12)
It was clear he refused to sit down when the officer attempted a leg sweep. Maybe, just maybe, if he had sit down and followed orders, his nose would not be broken? It is the same in the US. It is unlawful to disobey an order from a law enforcement officer. You can be arrested for simply refusing to show an ID when asked for it by an officer. What we do know; this video is inflammatory because it has been edited.
68. softties
Carlos ,   Mexico   (07.27.12)
Those israeli soldiers use such a soft hand with suspects , in comparison with our "standards", no wonder they are not obeyed......softties
69. Next time put a bullet in his head.
Gill ,   Montréal   (07.27.12)
Save your headbut for learning
70. I don't see any head-butting here
R. Brosilow ,   Rehovot, Israel   (07.27.12)
I don't see any head-butting here
71. In America...
(07.27.12)
That would be called resisting arrest. In Israel for some reason that is called abuse. How sad.
72. @ Rashid, # 16
M. Davison ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (07.27.12)
Then, according to you, murdering five people is a "proper retaliation" for a broken nose (unconfirmed)? If that's the case, what's your opinion of the "proper retaliation" for murdering five people? Levelling the entire town they came from? You make a statement like yours, then have the unmitigated gall to cry "FOUL!" and claim "disproportional force". It reminds me of the schoolyard bully caught fighting who tells his teacher, "It all started when he hit be back!"
73. I would like to know what went on between shots
zionist forever   (07.27.12)
We didn't see the whole story there, obviously the soldier was angry with this teen for something. I get the impression that at first at least the soldier may have felt threatened in some way or the teenager had gone out of his way to anger him and then afterwards he realises his mistake and agrees to be submissive by which time its to late.
74. Where's the head-butt?
M. Davison ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (07.27.12)
Not only can't I find any head-butt on the video, I can't find anything near the amount of blood one would expect from a head-butt to the face. In my experience, noses broken by fists or foreheads are pretty bloody injuries, with a free flow from the nostrils that covers a large part of the lower face and most of the shirt. There's no such blood flow evident here... could it be that this is another phantom injury? We all know how honest the PA medics are when it comes to describing injuries and their causes...
75. I love these videos.
golan ,   modiin   (07.27.12)
they show 1. that the Left and Arabs stage these incidents 2. that our soldiers have to deal with a very hard situation 3. that despite the provocations our soldiers act like human beings and not... say like Syrians, Egyptians, or Balestinians when faced with provocations 4. that the Left orchestrates these shows and put people (Israelis and Arabs) in danger for their make believe world.
76. Not getting full story this way.
Barbara ,   Haifa Israel   (07.27.12)
No one giving soldier's side of story ?
77. No Jews involved with B'Tselem
Haim ,   T-A   (07.27.12)
They could not possibly be such idiots as to provide such a lie. It has all the foot prints of an arab job. This looks as twisted as my walls and ceilings. Show the whole footage if you want some sort of credibility
78. I'm still waiting for ...
Antonio ,   Spharad   (07.27.12)
... videos about how kassam missiles are prepared, launched with the terrorists' faces uncovered, just like IDF officers appear in this one. I'm very tired of these 'poor Pals' and their 'ever martyr' role.
79. 74
zionist forever   (07.27.12)
I also don't see any head butt but at the same time Krav Maga teaches you to use all of your body as a weapon not just your fists so a head butt is possible. An advantage of the head butt is it allows you to use your hands to keep the enemy controlled and you can use your head as the weapon to fight. Head butt or not there is defantly more to this than some angry soldier who decided to attack this kid just for the hell of it and to much of it took place out of the sight of the camera we caught just part of it.
80. ki soldiers revenge
brian ,   Dublin Ireland   (07.27.12)
81. we should
daniela ,   panama   (07.27.12)
invite B´tselem video guys to bulgaria.. maybe they could make a movie also of what the other side is ready to do...then maybe they will realize that a broken nose it´s nothing
82. Or, maybe those 'humiliating' terror attacks?
bad Ased Jew ,   United States   (07.27.12)
got this lizard annoyed because he couldn't complete the act of terror he originally came out to perform. What an idiot.
83. # 21 Gary Hess yes add to that his legs, arms,
Bad Ased Jew ,   United States   (07.27.12)
any bone they could. Terrorists should be put down as mad dogs.
84. So what !
So what ! ,   Thornhill, Canada   (07.27.12)
A head but and Betselem is all over the place. How about 200 people killed every day in Syria ?
85. how long?
Michael Lesher ,   Passaic, USA   (07.27.12)
I don't know which is more disgusting: another act of violence by Israeli thugs in occupied territory, or the vulgar cheering section that, once again, roars its approval on this page. Perhaps it is useless to protest -- but a Jew must.
86. #77 - you're aligned with Israeli Leftists in TA
William ,   Israel   (07.27.12)
and you're saying that you've never run into Israeli Leftists who are anti-Israel and pro-"Palestinian" to the point that they'd lie and manipulate for their agenda? Does Yariv Oppenheimer, Tali Fahima, and Adam Shapiro (American Jew of ISM fame), just to name a few, ring a bell??
87. IS NOT WHAT IT SEEMS!!
Cindy ,   Tel Aviv Israel   (07.27.12)
Palestinian teenager was violent and the video was edited: Please read the article published by IMRA. http://www.imra.org.il/story.php3?id=57648
88. Big tough soldier
James ,   canada   (07.28.12)
IDF soldiers are great at abusing Palestinian children and teens.
89. If the roles were reversed
James ,   canada   (07.28.12)
Funny, if the roles were reversed and an Arab Soldier headbutted a Jewish teen...would you all say the same thing? Doubtful. All of the Israeli apologists here are just blind racists.
90. The gospel side
Jagouar ,   x at any thing   (07.28.12)
I think the gospel side for Israel at the right side, which can talk much about plants samples in gospel and life too .
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article