News
Lebanese website blames Hizbullah for Qana deaths
Roee Nahmias
Published: 01.08.06, 07:53
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
136 Talkbacks for this article
61. #53 Mick. i forgot: sign the petition - help israel
gerd schulz ,   germany   (08.01.06)
i know, mick, you already did.... The State of Israel is in crisis now and needs your support more than ever before. Help Israel - Sign the Petition  http://globaljewish.com/
62. no muslim outrage
gerd schulz ,   germany   (08.01.06)
Muslims fly commercial airliners into buildings in New York City. No Muslim outrage. Muslim officials block the exit where school girls are trying to escape a burning building because their faces were exposed. No Muslim outrage. Muslims cut off the heads of three teenaged girls on their way to school in Indonesia. A Christian school. No Muslim outrage. Muslims murder teachers trying to teach Muslim children in Iraq. No Muslim outrage. Muslims murder over 80 tourists with car bombs outside cafes and hotels in Egypt. No Muslim outrage. A Muslim attacks a missionary children's school in India. Kills six. No Muslim outrage. Muslims slaughter hundreds of children and teachers in Beslan, Russia. No Muslim outrage. Let's go way back. Muslims kidnap and kill athletes at the Munich Summer Olympics. No Muslim outrage. Muslims fire rocket-propelled grenades into schools full of children in Israel. No Muslim outrage. Muslims murder more than 50 commuters in attacks on London subways and busses. Over 700 are injured. No Muslim outrage. Muslims massacre dozens of innocents at a Passover Seder. No Muslim outrage. Muslims murder innocent vacationers in Bali. No Muslim outrage. Muslim newspapers publish anti-Semitic cartoons. No Muslim outrage Muslims are involved, on one side or the other, in almost every one of the 125+ shooting wars around the world. No Muslim outrage. Muslims beat the charred bodies of Western civilians with their shoes, then hang them from a bridge. No Muslim outrage.
63. To Mary #56, It's true. I read Lebanese Forces
Christian Bianrossa   (08.01.06)
I found this post on there: "Yesterday I met several persons coming from ain ebel and rmeich Among them several religious They confirmed me that several time Hezbollah used their village to fire their BM21 ROCKET LUNCHER, they beg them to stop but the hezb militiamen’s continued Until they were hit and eliminated They told that several ad several problem with el hizb who insisted to hide rockets in Christian house But unfortunaly the ain ebel people don’t dare to publicly declare the incidents My question if they send their stories to this mail, do you guarantee their anonymous"
64. #56 - thank you very interesting read
(08.01.06)
65. hizbulla crimes against humanity.
g.man ,   manchester. u.k.   (08.01.06)
Is it possible Kofi Anan could investigate this,or is he happy to blame Israel.(as usual) Where was his unifil patrols when 600 tunnells were being dug some up to 90 metres deep. where was the lebanese army when the above was happening. Who will make millions when lenanon gets rebuilt. Does something start to stink,ignore it blame Israel.
66. Qana death
Joe   (08.01.06)
Please be reminded that on the day of the massacre, Hizbollah did not fire rockets from Qana. (Israel UN Ambassador failed to prove otherwise).The decision was made by the IAF and their intelligence. U cant expect us to believe that H/lloh have access to the airforce to guide them where and when to strike to create this un-believable scenario. Right or wrong, kindly remember that the ends doesnt justify the means. And you know what is the funny part, the whole world still share with you these excuses.
67. Hizbollah cruelly exploiting childrens deaths for photo ops
Nannette ,   London, UK   (08.01.06)
These photos show the sick minds of Hzbollah! Were the Qana bodies staged? http://confederateyankee.mu.nu/archives/188571.php Hizbollah are Milking it http://eureferendum.blogspot.com/2006/07/milking-it.html Who is this man? http://eureferendum.blogspot.com/2006/07/who-is-this-man.html
68. to #11. they fill dishonoured, not mourned
Arabians Go Back ,   To Arabia   (08.01.06)
They do not mourne their dead, they feel dishonoured that *Jews* killed them. Evidence: watch in those videos of Qana how they go around carrying corpses of little children in the open, with no regard to their (the dead) decency. They *show them off*. Compare in Beslan massacre the parents of children wipping over coffins of their children. The Jews are the last reminder to Arabians that they are invaders in the "Arab World" which they took over by plunder, rape, murder and enslavement in their GREAT GENOCIDE campain of 7th century, whiping out dozens of indigenous peoples and cultures of which only the Jews are left. Arabians don't like to be reminded of their murderous heritage.
69. nasralla u should take ur big ass and push it somewhere alse
Michal 15 years old ,   Israel i wan to live   (08.01.06)
70. Lindon Richards and all Zionists
MD ,   Dubai, UAE   (08.01.06)
This is truly a sad comment which indicates your utter lack of knowledge concerning warfare in general and the Israeli record concerning human rights violations and the killing of innocent civilians in partcular. To refute your hate filled points : 1- The rateof children deaths is in line with the 45% child kill rate by Israel since the beginning of this conflict and is supported by the region's demographics. The fact is that most of the refugees were members of extended families and because some were disabled and most roads out were destroyed by Israel they had no choice but to take shelter in the basement. 2- It took place in Qana simply because Israel has no regard to this issue of supposed 'sensitivity' just as it didnt when it bombed Qana in 2000 - a UN facility at that. 3-Israel has knowledge that civilians deaths will result in most of its attacks as indicated by its record so far and its record in Palestine. Israel reasonably expected that bombing civilian areas with raid after raid of multi-ton US ordinance designed for miltary warfare would kill people. Lots of people. It is at a minumim guilty of negligence and most probably of a war crime. 4- Israel indeed has the capability to guide precision attacks but hasnot demonstraed this during the conflict - given the mouning civilian death toll. This is clear indication of knowingly targeting civilians. If Israel as a state was tried in a cour of international law it would be an open and shut guilty verdict. Israel is a pariah state and is a textbook example of how to identify human rights violations. It will be remembered years from now as a more sinister version of the Apartheid regime in South Africa that was too allowed to become a nuclear superpower and remain unchecked for generations to please political US interests that no-one will even remember 50 years from now. Israeli adults will finally be ashamed of their grandparents when Israel ceases being a Jewish state and the Arab popuation becomes the majority ruled by Zionists.
71. Self-Deception
AHM ,   UK   (08.01.06)
Historically, Israeli is intentionally killing innocent civilians people without any respect for international treaties concerning the right of childern and people to live and even UN observers. By the way, it is not the first time for Israel to target civilians, but many times in Labenon and Palestine. THEREFORE, logically we cannot claim that hizbullah are merely responsible for this cruel mass killing of isolated childern and civilians because of ridiculous claims without rigorous and appearant evidence by Independent Investigation of Gana incident that hizbullah is installing Rocket launcher at civilians' houses.
72. Zionist Propaganda Will Get u NOWHERE
AK47 ,   lebanon   (08.01.06)
Does the isreali population really want peace with its neighbhors? coz if that is not the case i am sorry to tell u will never live in peace.Every lebanese is seeing the truth coz they are living it and when ur government tries to show u that they are targetting hizbulla when they are actually killing civilians YOUR PEOPLE HAVE JUST WON ATLEAST 4 MORE GENERATIONS OF HATRED FROM THE ARAB PEOPLE!!!
73. All in time for Sunday Morning Newspapers/TV.Best exposure.
Alan ,   SA   (08.01.06)
74. Here Is the proof that hizzbullah did it
Josef Stalin ,   Russia   (08.01.06)
http://yaakov.newsvine.com/_news/2006/08/01/307754-questions-on-qana?r=386208683
75. #70 MD Dubai
(08.01.06)
Just like a mushroom. Fed bullshit and living in the dark
76. PROPAGANDA PROPAGANDA
LEBANESE CHRISTIAN ,   Beirut   (08.01.06)
Just another of the Israeli propaganda. The TRUTH is CHRISTIANS in Lebanon consider Israel our prime enemy and blames it for killing our civilians 30% of them children!!! Good job Israel, are you gonna say now that those children are hizbullah fighters?
77. Is it moral to kill a human sheild?
Judith Sharko ,   Portsmouth, NH USA   (08.01.06)
Maybe it is right to allow the killing of a human shield under certain circumstances? You are on a plane with your family when a terrorist (possibly with a bomb) appears with a gun pressed to the head of a passenger. Do you want the air marshall to shoot the terrorist (knowing the passenger will be killed) to prevent the whole plane from exploding?
78. History falsely reported in the past leads to a credibility
Judith Sharko ,   Portsmouth   (08.01.06)
Where are your recommendations and concern for the humane treatment of Palestinians living in Lebanon? For many years I read and accepted the accusation holding Ariel Sharon responsible for the slaughter of the Palestinian civilians residing in the Sabra and Shatilla camps. I became interested in the Middle East and started reading about the history of the area. Imagine my surprise to learn that the civilians in those camps were slaughtered by Lebanese Arabs (Phalangists), who remain nameless in any readily available historical accounts. Why do I never find condemnation of butchers who committed the actual slaughter? Is there a written resource explaining the details of this attack, naming the militia leaders who participated and where they are today? Failing to be forthcoming with the horrible details of this incident makes me question the credibility of the current verbal attacks. Are Palestinians held in high regard by your country today? Are they encouraged to engage in higher education, become professionals, acquire a higher standard of living and if born there become citizens? A knowledgeable answer to my question would be welcomed, no propaganda please!
79. #2 Shadi - Hizbollah are evil propagandists
Nannette ,   London, UK   (08.01.06)
Let's face it, only Islamic terrorists use dead bodies and recycle them, just to get their propaganda of lies out to the world. Christians and Jews have more respect for their dead.
80. let's not forget Mohammed al-Dura either
BS meter ,   Canada   (08.01.06)
81. this thing
the one and only ,   Iran   (08.01.06)
I love you Mr. Potatohead!
82. (for 80) Mohammed Al-Dura
Ann ,   Israel   (08.01.06)
You're right! Nobody should ever forget that horrible LIE! http://seconddraft.org/streaming/aldurah.wmv
83. #78 Arabs kill Arabs and they blame Jews
Elle ,   USA   (08.01.06)
The Arabs blame Ariel Sharon for Sabra and Shatilla when an Arab Syrian ally massacred those people. FYI his name was Eli Hobeika. You never hear this name associated with S & S but it is historical fact. ARABS KILL HUNDREDS OF THEIR OWN PEOPLE DAILY BUT WILL NEVER ADMIT IT AND NEVER PROTEST IT. The world has woken up. Europe is afraid but we are not. We have looked evil in the face before and we will do it again. Whoever is with us, is with us. Period
84. cartoon about this
Jaime ,   Lisbon, Portugal   (08.01.06)
I think this cartoon sums it up pretti nicely: http://omwo.blogspot.com/2006/07/15-minutes-of-fame-nasrallah-style.html
85. Responsibility
Maarten ,   Utrecht, Netherlands   (08.01.06)
This would imply that Israel is cooporating with Hezbullah. Sounds strange to me. Who is directly responsible for this 'accident'? I don't think the general who fired his rockets on Qana thought: let's help Hezbollah give Israel a bad name.
87. Qana massacre
Marlowe Anderson ,   Victoria, B.C.   (08.02.06)
I do hope there is a credible way to establish that this was a put-up job by Hizbullah gunmen -- photos, eye witnesses willing to testify, etc. Nonetheless, Israel IDF need our thoughts and prayers to succeed in the necessary work of crippling, if not annihilating, Hizbullah forces.
88. Mistranslation in article.
Paul in California ,   Los Angeles   (08.02.06)
This has a mistranslation of the French article. Where it says, "Knowing full well that Israel will not hesitate to bombard civilian targets" it should read, "Knowing very well that Israel does not wish to bomb civilian targets." Here is the original French phrase. "Sachant très bien qu’Israël n’aura pas d’état d’âme pour bombarder des cibles civiles." This mistake should be corrected as it makes all the difference in the article.
89. same man on all those pictures
rommie ,   the netherlands   (08.02.06)
http://eureferendum.blogspot.com/2006/07/who-is-this-man.html
90. Zionist Propaganda
Assistant Village Id ,   Goffstown, US   (08.02.06)
#72, you accuse that Israel has won four more generations of hatred from the Arab people. How would we tell the difference?
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article