Jewish Scene
Neturei Karta: IDF conducting ethnic cleansing in Gaza
Neta Sela
Published: 17.01.08, 14:59
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
104 Talkbacks for this article
61. A good start...
Micha   (01.17.08)
to their proposed ethnic cleansing...get the NK out of Israel. They are racist and traitors. They cavort with the Iranian establishment to declare the Holocaust a fairy tale. They are beyond disgusting.
62. to ayman!
oded   (01.17.08)
stupidity and hatred are incurable... don't even bother with medications.....
63. This time
charles ,   petach tikva   (01.17.08)
no attacks on the Charidim . And with reason , those NK's are rejected by the whole Israeli Jewish community , not only by the National Religious , the seculars , but also by the Charidim themselve [ sorry if i forgot someone ] Sadly to say , there is no high religious court who can put an universal cherem on them .
64. #55 response to a post by Abpaqcharin
Josh   (01.17.08)
I see now you named yourself after your false god Jesus. It should say Charles instead of Yehoshua on your post. I'm sorry, I mean it should say Paqid. You state that I like to spout Torah. Yes this is the one and only thing you have ever stated that was true. I am glad and a bit surprised you recognize anything as Torah. By the way Moses and the other 11 tribes did the shema and "spouted" Torah while they walk on their way, when they arouse and when they went down. They taught it to their children and bound it as a symbol between their eyes and on their hands. None of them were Jewish only Judah was and non of them clained as you falsely claim that they are an orthodox athiest. Of course you as a missionizer would have a problem with people recognizing Torah as you try to trick them into following Jesus and we know Torah dispproves your claims. Why dont you stick to posting in bad high school level french. Then you can keep to talking to yourself and say "Cher Ami" in the mirror. I am proud that I quote Torah. You should try reading it sometime. G-d has not chosen nor informed any of my bretherin that they are the Messiah. But it doesn;t mean that that child or man who will fill these boots does not exist. I hope there is one among us who deserves that title. It wont be you. If G-d were to select me or anyone else at the end of time to be the Messiah, he would need to shut fools up so we could listen. You make so much worthless noise.
65. Yacoub sulleiman - you would admire them
oodles   (01.17.08)
Says something about your logic, doesnt it? But you being christain who thinks he is a jew, that doesnt say much. personally, their gay marriage stance is abt the only thing I agree with them on. but then again perhaps we are better off if you do not breed,
66. Historic Palestine? Aren't they waiting for the messiah to
come so Israel can ,   be established again   (01.17.08)
Doesn't saying it is Historic Palestine conflict with their supposed belief that Israel is historically Jewish and will be again in the future after the coming of the messiah?
67. Destiny of Zionism
George Saliba ,   Canada   (01.17.08)
German get ride of Nazism after they figured how mach distraction this bring to Germany. No matter what it will stay as dark patch in the German history and memory for centuries to come. The Russian get ride of communism after this ideology dragged the society to nowhere eve though it brings to them the victory. The same destiny is awaiting for Zionism which has both, regardless it bring the victory for Israel it patched for ever the history of Jews with the same German dark memory.
68. Palestine should be given over to Hamas
Shulamit   (01.17.08)
Hamas is the democratically elected government of Palestine. We must end the zionist occupation immediately and turn the land over to them. Only a fascist neoconservative would oppose Hamas.
69. to #16
Tobias   (01.17.08)
You say that goyyim who love Israel, are Enemies? Do mean enemies of Israel, or on which side are you? So if you regard even those as enemies who love Israel, who do you think are you friends (or don't you have any at all)?
70. "IDF conducting ethnic cleansing in Gaza" - August 2005
Tobias ,   Germany   (01.17.08)
"IDF conducting ethnic cleansing in Gaza" - this headline would have been appropriate in Summer 2005, when the Gaza Strip had been cleansed from its non-arab parts of population. In the current context of some battles between the IDF and palestinian armed groups (which are everything else than innocent themselves), the use of this term is grotesque. If this is ethnic cleansing, then the inhabitants of the Gaza Strip already commited ethnic cleansing against themselves, e.g. in Jan. 2006 and in May/June 2007, when they killed more of them each other, than the IDF is killing now. Also, the term "ethnical cleansing" suggests that IDF killed Palestinians without reason, and in large number in order to significantly reduce their population. Both is false. The fighting is a direct result of the continuous bombardment of Sderot, Ashkelon and neighboring villages, and if Israel intended to commit ethnic cleansing in the Gaza Strip, there wouldn't be any Gaza Strip anymore within one week. If they intentionally wanted to kill many civilians, thousands would die daily. To suggest that the IDF wanted to kill many people, but wasn't able, is absolutely ridiculous.
71. By their names shall G-d know the blasphemers of NK
Russel ,   Tlv   (01.17.08)
72. Watch "Israel"
Zeal ,   Zionist America   (01.17.08)
You ignore the warnings of the pious amongst you in arrogance. You will bring your sufferings upon yourself. Your fears are all part of guilty and sinful past. The 'driving of the sea?' That you've done to Jaffa. 'Nuclear weapons?' These you've concealed for forty years and forbid others from having. 'Wiping off the map?' That you did to Palestine. Face it- you are your own destroyers.
73. Not Representative
Jakov   (01.17.08)
This group is not representative of the Jewish People. They don't represent the viewpoints of the people, and they don't represent mine. It's a good thing their numbers are small. I would not want to see that our investment in Israel has come to nought. Israel was, and always will be a home for the Hewish people. It's absolutely necessary that it be there for those who need it..
74. Even my relatives aren't as annoying as these guys
Steve G ,   Kew Gardens, NY, USA   (01.17.08)
Newspapers keep these guys around to help on slow news days. There are so few NK are probably lucky to raise a minyan on most days.
75. NK
Paul Schnek ,   NewYork,USA.   (01.17.08)
How timely! Just last Sabath we read about them. They still around poisoning the athmosphere like their ancestors.Send this erevrav to Egypt-or-better yet to Gaza. they will experience first hand their brotherly love with the so called Palestinians.
76. Corruption
Ben Plonie ,   Galus, Chutz LaAretz   (01.17.08)
Throw these creeps in jail for 'incitement', treason and insulting public officials, not schoolgirls in Jewish Palestine
77. Make Them At Home In Gaza
Bill Foonman ,   Jacksonville, USA   (01.17.08)
These losers are not much use to Israel or anyone else.
78. recommended reading
peter ,   amsterdam NL   (01.17.08)
Check out Aviezer Ravitzky's book 'Messianism, Zionism and Jewish Religious Radicalism'(Univ. of Chicago Press 1996) originally published in Hebrew as 'Ha kets ha megulah we medina ha yehudim: meshichi'ut, tsionut we radikalism dati be Israel'(Am Oved 1993). It deals with the issue of 'hastening the end(of the exile)' and the religious philosophical backgrounds of opposition to a secular Jewish state before 'the coming of the maschiah'. I found it compelling reading.
79. #27--Amen! 100% correct
David ,   Montreal, Canada   (01.18.08)
80. Neturai Karta: the only Jews worthy of the name.
Chanalau, Tova ,   London, UK   (01.18.08)
Zionists: something else again. More in keeping with happenings in Europe in the 1930s and 40s
81. "The pious among you" LOL, that is funny
Jake   (01.18.08)
Let's get this straight. All that glitters is not gold, and one is not pious who appears to be so outwardly. These NK "pious ones" may have peyot the length of the Amazon and shtremels the size of Uranus, and claim to be "good Jews", but that does not necessarily make it so! The joke is on you, my friend.
82. To George Saliba
Jake   (01.18.08)
Gee whiz, I wonder how many Salibas they will allow to remain in the new Palestine, or anywhere in the Islamic Middle East, for that matter. Israel and Zionism is your excuse to avoid facing this painful reality.
83. Book:Zioninm Messianism etc.
Paul Schnek ,   NewYork US.   (01.18.08)
I whole heartedly reccomend to read a former Nat,K. leaders book, titled EIM HABANIM SEMEICHAH. The writer explains cristal clear the reason and motive of NK. He points it out that is nothing but HilulHASEM. It is a must read for anyone interested in this matter
84. My post #73, I meant "Jewish" My error
Jakov   (01.18.08)
85. So Why Are They Even Living In Israel?
emanon ,   USA   (01.18.08)
86. Chareidi papers
Lea Wow, Shlechter ,   PG Israel   (01.18.08)
have not printed this Stum ferd Hill garbage. Good for them
87. Antisemites in diguise
Jon   (01.18.08)
All these people are is sick antisemites in disguise who go against what the torah says.
88. Do orthdox Rabbis permit usury in Shemita year?
observer   (01.18.08)
"Israel must not have a prophet to tell them how to do Torah" so, Israel did not need Moses to have a Torah. Neither do Israel need a G-d; Israel has Rabbis. 1Sa 15:18 And the LORD sent thee on a journey, and said, Go and utterly destroy the sinners the Amalekites, and fight against them until they be consumed. Psa 106:37-38 37 Yea, they sacrificed their sons and their daughters unto devils, 38 And shed innocent blood, [even] the blood of their sons and of their daughters, whom they sacrificed unto the idols of Canaan: and the land was polluted with blood. Some peace loving Rabbis are so lovely that they advocate Talmudic teachings!
89. Iran is minority of minority, as well
(01.18.08)
Shiits are less than 10 % of Muslims. Iranian Shiits 30% of Shiits.
90. Idiots
Bobby ,   Canada   (01.18.08)
After living in Israel for 3 yrs These idiots are as dangerous as any muslim terrorist All in the name of GOD
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article