News
Israel declares unilateral Gaza truce
Roni Sofer
Published: 17.01.09, 23:34
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
114 Talkbacks for this article
91. talking baout digging your own grave
ziad ,   lebanon   (01.18.09)
we used to see this in mafia movies or western movies now israel has dugg their own grave tarnished their reputaion ,hamass still there ,still have 10.000 missiles more screwed up situation i can 't get !!
92. You've won, actually
Brian ,   Jerusalem   (01.18.09)
This war may have achieved everything you could have reasonably set out to do. The 2006 war was not necessarily a failure - you haven't had a serious rocket problem from Lebanon since; not even during this war. You may have beaten Hamas enough for them to make the same calculation that Hezbollah has made about the level of violence Israel is willing to visit on anyone who fires rockets at them. And, unlike with Hezbollah, you might have convinced Egypt to get serious about smuggling, thereby severely limiting Hamas resupply. I don't like the way you did it - you killed far too many children and innocent civilians. But take what you have. Don't hanker after more blood. Many of you want Gilad Shalit back. Fair enough. But many Palestinians want prisoners released and the occupation of the West Bank to end. If you look for "total victory" (i.e. we get everything and we give nothing in return) then you will only be able to achieve at the expense of more lives (Israeli and Palestinian), at an immense cost to Israel's global reputation and with the result that the two-state solution will be dead. And in the long run the absence of such a solution threatens Israel as much, if not more, than it threatens the Arab world. You've won. Hamas have shown themselves to be not only murderous but also impotent. Now is the time for magnanimity. Open the crossings. Try and restore some normality to the lives of the ordinary people of Gaza. It is not in your interests to create a failed state on your border or to give the Gazan people a reason to hate Israel as much as they have a genuine reason to hate Hamas.
93. Olmert does not learn
Paolo Ortenzi ,   Rome, Italy   (01.18.09)
Making a war to say "BOOOOH" to your enemy is a waste of resources and human lives from both sides. Again Olmert stops because seduced by appeasing UN pressures. A UN that NEVER protected Israel against rockets from Hizballa nor from Hamas ones. For the record: WP IS NOT forbidden by any protocol. British journalists are on Arab payroll.
94. To 81
Daniel ,   madrid, Spain   (01.18.09)
You should go to school again. Israel killed 1200 civilians? please....tell a lie that we can believe, even Hamas can't talk of 1200 civilians death. And by the way, the israeli deads were ISRAELI people, not settlers in Gaza or the West Bank so...have a nice day
95. Objectives achieved ?
Brad ,   US   (01.18.09)
1) International condemnation. 2) International disgust. 3) International hatred Yes Israel has met ALL these objectives. Congratulations.
96. Excuse me?
kay ,   usa   (01.18.09)
"In a statement following the vote, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said Israel fully achieved the operation's objectives..." All I've read and heard is that the objectives were to change the "reality" on the ground, including an end to the rocket firing. So since that hasn't happened, what exactly were the REAL objectives of all this operation? Just to pound our chest and show how powerful we are? FINISH THE JOB!!
97. #78 typical Zionist menthality,who kill more gain respect at
George ,   Canada   (01.18.09)
least for 21 days.
98. Gaza has been given one more chance to clean up....
David ,   Hartford USA   (01.18.09)
Or the bombings will begin again and the Gazans will get the chance to live underground for years at a time. Either they disarm Hamas themselves or they have nothing to complain about when Bibi and the IDF go back in and finish the job. G-d Bless the IDF. Keep your eyes open! Just because the cabinet decided to 'call it a day' doesn't mean Hamas has changed their tune by a single note.
99. Intermission...
Richard ,   USA   (01.18.09)
hey...wait...its gonna get better.God bless our idf.
100. wasn't a vote supposed 2 be taken???
clu ,   usa   (01.18.09)
101. Wipe Hamas out
Yetzhak ,   Keryat Shmona   (01.18.09)
The results are not comfortable or fulfilling. We should wipe Hamas Out. This is such a depressing situation
102. Incident
Hamsawi ,   Jordan   (01.18.09)
One of the worst incidents that happened to IDF is that a Hamas fighter kidnapped a soldier and an Apache shot the kidnapper and the soldier. This goes to show how much Israel cares about its IDFs. RIP IDF
103. And the Winner is
Asad ,   Jordan   (01.18.09)
HAMAS - with no doubt
104. now what?
Yakov ,   Germany   (01.18.09)
Ok if you wanna cease fire that's fine, but what the heck are you still doing in Gaza? static target for hamas?
105. Last week
Ahmed ,   Jordan   (01.18.09)
Last week, a Hmas fighter kidnapped an IDF soldier. guess what the Appaches did? they shot the kidnapper and the IDF. BOTH!!
106. Unjustified War.
Jewish Refugee ,   U.S.A.   (01.18.09)
Israel has lost over 1,000,000,000 in revenues due to this war. Israel has lost soldiers to this war. Israel lost PR war. Israel did not reach its objectives: Kassams still falling, Hamas is still operational Gilad is still in captivity This war is unjustified so why did this government do this at all? ELEEEEECTIONS. Also the only reason that Israel was able to succeed military was because of Gabi Acshkinazi and military staff not because of this Kamima and Labor curse. This undone operation is a political suicide to both parties. Farewell Kadima and Labor. For more please visit: http://israelactnow.blogspot.com/ Brothers and Sister we will overcomes this diffictult times.
107. Merely a delay, kids.
Cameron ,   USA   (01.18.09)
Now we simply wait for a replay of exactly the same scenario. You know, without fail, that headcase Hamas will work toward the same setup/round #2. I truly advise every Gaza family that can to get their children out during this short breathing spell.
108. Truce is not valid as long as IDF is in Gaza
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (01.18.09)
You cannot make cheasefire as long as you continue occupy Gaza Palestinians should go on defending themselves and drive of Israeli army from Gaza
109. Truce
Wolfgang ,   München   (01.18.09)
Ceasefire in Gaza is not valid as long as Israel exists You do realy not understand them
110. 81
zionst forever   (01.18.09)
muhanned Israel has lost this war but not because Hamas were a superior enemy but because we have inferior politicians. If our politicians operated as well as our soilders then Hamas would have been smashed and then any unilateral ceasefire would be based on Israels terms. The palestinians have been seeking peace for 60 years now thats a good joke. Since the creation of the PLO when a group of arabs identified themselves as palestinians its goal was the destruction of Israel and its replacement with an arab state. In 1993 Arafat signed oslo which he personly described as a trojan horse and how 2 states was stage 1 in the liberation of all Palestine and he would never give up even 1 inch of it. We got nothing but terror even after the signing of oslo and the PLO never changed their charter like oslo demanded so even today legaly the PLO doesnt recognise Israels right to exist full stop. There is a palestinian state in existence they call it Jordan so your right the 1 state solution is the best one .. Jordan will be the palestinian state Israel will anex Judea & Samaria and the refugee return fantasy will never be anything but a fantasy with no legal binding under international law. Another palestinian state in Judea & Samaria is not physicly viable. Water supply ( some aquifers will be shard to Israel, Israel will get full soverignty of some palestiinians of others but generaly there isnt enough water to go around. Israel at least has the Kineret. As a lack of agricultural land the majority of your food will be imports. You have a small qualntity of natural gas off the Gaza coast but nothing special $1-$2 billion worth at best and its going to take more than that to rebuild Gaza. Some fishing rights but again this is not enough to sustain the country. Its going to be divided into 2 parts and Israel will have soverignty over the crossings. You wont be allowed a military to defend yourself so what happens if you are invaded in future by Israel or any other country? Your education system doesn't come close to Israel. You dont have the allies. Not as much as during the cold war but Israel can still offer countries like the US more than palestinian state could. Israel was also built on western culture any palestinian state will be based on arab culture and the west prefer their own... the love for the lost cause will die out around most the world if a palestinian state came into being all the supporters you see now its a tempory measure. A second palestinian state just isn't viable and the jews will never accept the arab idea of Israel becoming the next arab majority state rather than a jewish one. You should also get your facts straight .. jewish living in Sderot, Ashkelon, Ashdod and Beerhsheva are not settlers they are civilians. So both soilders and civilians have been murdered by Hamas whose terror led to this war.
111. 108
zionist forever   (01.18.09)
Israel wasnt defeated by Hamas it was defeated by its own government and their idiot political solutions on how to wrap up a war. The IDF have nothing to be ashamed of they rose to the chalange and they excelled ten soilders dead most of them in a friendly fire incident which must be investigated. This government must be punished at the election and we must get a Likud/ Yisrael Beitanu coalition and Labour & Kadima humiliated.
112. Hamas still able to talk?
just dave ,   Tallahassee, FL   (01.18.09)
Then the job is not finished. Keep fighting, Israel.
113. A DEFEAT! Israel & Entire Free World BETRAYED!
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (01.18.09)
Israeli Leaders Desire Neither PEACE Or VICTORY Re-take Gaza! Peace is achieved via utter DEFEAT of the enemy! Barbaric Islamics wage war to kill and conquer. A despicable unilateral truce signals weakness and surrender to savage enemies - inviting ever-increasing attacks. Israel's shameful government FORCE innocent Israelis to accept a daily barrage of rockets. Creating a PLO/Palestinian Authority Muslim Terror State in Judea, Samaria, Gaza and Jerusalem is the top priority. Stopping the genocide of Jews by barbaric hordes is considered irrelevant! Hamas TV video teaches that bombs that kill Israelis are more precious to an Arab mother than her children. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YIBNRVgq59Y Religious HATE and Religious MURDER of Jews and other non-Muslims is taught in mosques worldwide. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=buzRV-t5fLM&feature=related PA Muslims CHEERING murders of Americans on 9/11 Hamas Charter: 'Israel, by virtue of its being Jewish and of having a Jewish population, defies Islam and the Muslims. Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it, just as it obliterated others before it. Flash Video-What the West needs to know about jihad: http://www.terrorismawareness.org/know-about-jihad/ Israeli government-live in Sderot and Ashkelon! Experience the daily horror of Islamic war! Hamas Member of Parliament Fathi Hammad, February 29, 2008 on Al-Aqsa TV that for PA Arabs, "death has become an industry at which women excel… The elderly excel at this, and so do the mujahideen and the children." Translated by MEMRI, Hammad : "This is why they have formed human shields of the women, the children, the elderly and the mujahideen, in order to challenge the Zionist bombing machine. It is as if they were saying to the Zionist enemy: 'We desire death like you desire life.' An Israeli hospital treated a Muslim - she returned strapped with a bomb belt to blow up amongst the Jewish doctors and nurses who helped her, but was caught.
114. Brad US #95
Brad ,   USA   (01.20.09)
His first name might be the same as mine, but please don't think that this Jew Hater is me. From what he wrote, he's either a Muslim coward, or a US or EU lemming. Hey Brad US #95 Jew Hater, either wise up and change your behavior, or change your name.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article