Jewish Scene
Neturei Karta protest Holocaust Day
Ynet
Published: 03.05.11, 15:16
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
49 Talkbacks for this article
1. OMG! These people are disgusting!
Matt ,   Israel   (05.03.11)
2. Nutty Cards are again spitting
rachel ,   chutz4 now home soon   (05.03.11)
in their own well! maybe they should go to iran? i am religious and zionist. people like this and the arab mks and the far away lefts should know that they are only at home in israel! everywhere else they are just expendable.
3. I bet a lot of talkbacks got censored for...
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (05.03.11)
threatening violence on these guys.
4. They are beyond vile, and why do they do it
Talula ,   Israel   (05.03.11)
because they can - the government has NEVER EVER done anything to stop their offensive disgusting behaviour. The rest of us law abiding citizens have to eat ourselves up watching them do exactly as they please.
5. How do they make their living?
Anna   (05.03.11)
Do they receive child support benefits from the government of Israel? Do they communicate and cooperate in businesses with other orthodox branches? If they denounce Israeli citizenship how do they travel? Can their economical existence be scrutinized or it's a taboo?
6. letthem go to live in gaza where they can be supported there
Countess Mara   (05.03.11)
7. Naturei Karta
NYC Girl   (05.03.11)
Doesn't Israel have laws against sedition? These vermin have already met with and supported some of Israel's worst enemies. It's time to round them up and deport them to Brooklyn. Israelis already have enough crap to deal with.
8. NETUREI KARTA MAKES ME SICK !!!!!
BENJAMIN ,   SINGAPORE   (05.03.11)
SO CLEVER YET SO STUPID ! ANYWAY THESE BUNCH OF RABBIS ARE JEWS ALSO- WHAT AM I TO DO WITH THESE NETUREI KARTA ? NETYUREI KARTA , DONT COME TO SINGAPORE PLEASE !
9. naturei karta
Helene ,   Tel Aviv   (05.03.11)
How many are they anyway?? We should charter a few planes, fill them with these disgusting guys and send them to whoever wants them. OUT OF ISRAEL !!!!!!! NOW !!! Of course, as usual, the government does nothing and is good for nothing. Same story all over again
10. uneducated-unemployed -no benefit to society
a ash ,   jerusalem   (05.03.11)
11.  they just dress up as religious ...but are ennemies ...
rachel ,   usa   (05.03.11)
12. Confront them with counter protests.
Michael ,   California, USA   (05.03.11)
Civil disobedience can effectively be met by opposing civil disobedience. Government intervention can sometimes be effective, no doubt, but it will leave a lot of negative residue. If Israeli police suppressed those Neturei Karta elements, outcries would be heard from many directions. Not so if citizens went out and showed Neturei Karta what the popular opinions in Israel are. Otherwise, it is just a demonstration of opinions by Neturei Karta and the democratic State of Israel supports freedom of speech.
13. Naturei Karta
h.s.cohen ,   New York City U.S.A.   (05.03.11)
Bibbi: It's time to kick them out of Israel.
14. Neturei Karta
Marilyn Miller ,   South Africa   (05.04.11)
It is too terrible to discover that there are ultra religious Jews who burn the Jewish flag and paint swastika's on the flag. These people are despicable! They should be removed from Israel. They should have their Israeli Citizenship removed from them. They should receive absolutely no money from the Government. Get them out of Israel! They shame Israel!
15. Treason
Daniel ,   Jerusalem   (05.04.11)
Along with the Arab MK's who mis-use their freedoms and are in danger of loosing their citizenship also take it from these animals dressed as religious Jews. Remember these faces!!! Remember these animals when you walk on the street and give them any kind of respect, don't forget them.
16. They should be sanctioned
Tomi Weiss ,   Serbia   (05.04.11)
for burning Israeli flag,children should be allso protected and taken from them,Neuturei Karta should be outlowed,its memebers expelled from Israel.Their yeshivot should be closed down.
17. Deport them to Tehran where they belong
Avi ,   Israel   (05.04.11)
Anti zionist , naturally they dont mind living off that zionist tax money paid for by the Israeli tax payer, yes folks its your tax money that is paying for this so called life style of theirs apparently they are to holy to work , serve in the Army yet somehow they drag their holly ass`s down to the social security office like clock work.
18. They arent REAL Jews
Samg ,   NYC, USA   (05.04.11)
These loathsome, vile creatures who pretend to be Jews make me sick. Whether or not you are a Zionist (though if you pray each day - you mention Israel in every other paragraph so you cant "not be") thier behavior shows Jews and Christians the power of what the Torah calls the "Erev Rav" - people who pretend to be Jewish but know nothing about Judism. Good thing I didnt meet any last time I was there!
19. Theya are NOT JEWISH! They are KARET!
Israeli 2   (05.04.11)
They are SONEI YISRAEL!! Yes, it is Israel's or the Israelis' obligation to confront them harshly.
20. Israel's version of Fred Phelps?
Rob McGee ,   Virginia, USA   (05.04.11)
Fred Phelps is the American preacher/cultist who shows up at soldiers' funerals with anti-gay messages (GOD HATES FAGS), whether the soldier was gay or not. The Neturei Karta message may be a bit different, but they're basically worthless attention whores using "ultra-religious" language, just like the Phelps cult.
21. Neturei Karta are nothing but dreck.
Avi The Builder ,   Eretz Yisrael   (05.04.11)
Send them all to Gaza City.
22. Beasts on the rampage, jewish style
jo   (05.04.11)
Nothing to be done. Vile dogs are allowed to roam freely under " freedom of expression " with our Govt's blessings.
23. Give them their wish
Dave ,   Canada   (05.04.11)
They yearn for "the good old days" before Jews were able to defend themselves- import a regiment of Cossacks to Mea Shearim and let them have their "fun"
24. I wonder y YNET even publish the loony
ghostq   (05.04.11)
updates, this isn't something new, cults should not been given spot light in main streem news.
25. No. 20 Rob McGee
NYC Girl   (05.04.11)
While your comparison of the Naturei Karta to the Westboro Baptist Church is right on target, I would suggest to you that, unfortunately, the Naturei Karta aren't worthless. They're actually quite valuable to people like the little turd in Iran and to militant Palestinians and their terrorist supporters in the West. What Israel's enemies get from the NK is a public relations victory. Because every time they trot out these knuckle-dragging religious fanatics in their ultra-Orthodox garb, it potentially helps to convince people, who don't know the revolting truth about the Naturei Karta, that even these very pious Jews think the State of Israel shouldn't exist, and therefore neither should anybody else.
26. 3 talkbacks
COLIN   (05.04.11)
You can be assured that all talkbacks sent to Ynet that are not leftest and are truthfull WILL BE CENSERED Ynet only prints lies and falsehoods.
27. There are self hating left wing secular Jews....
American Sabrah   (05.04.11)
Who share the same hatred for the State of Israel as the Neturei Kartah. I am not condoning the Neturei Kartah in any way. In fact, I find their behavior to be reprehensible and an outright chillul Hashem. They must not taint the reputation of haredim either just like I wouldn't condemn hilonim over a few left wing zealots.The Neturei Kartah is just as anti- Zionist as the secular leftists. Truthfully, from the vantage point of a religious person, I find Yom Hashoa to be controversial. That shouldn't make me a flaming hater of Israel. I think the best time to commemorate the Holocaust should be on the 10th of Tevet. I have no religious issue with Yom Hazikaron and Yom Ha'atzmaut.I recognize them and celebrate them as a national holiday; not as a chag/yom tov. I have a problem with people who do.Just don't close your supermarkets earlier the day before any of those 2 holidays.
28. mass protest Neturei Karta
yoni ,   tel aviv   (05.04.11)
We must come out strongly against Neturei Karta and Left wing orgs who both support the enemies of our people. On Yom Hazikaron we must organize a large group to fill the square and take away all anti Israel propaganda from these crazy lunatics. I am religious and I know 99.9% of the religious jews in Israel including Charedim are behind me on this one Who's with me?
29. nothing
chava cooper ,   israel   (05.04.11)
i think they dont take anything from the state of israel. at least that...
30. #28 But Yoni
Haim ,   Tel Aviv   (05.04.11)
But Yoni dear your living in the secular capital of Israel , surrounded by secular people however do you manage ?
Next talkbacks
Back to article