News  Magazine
Tourists venture to West Bank to 'shoot terrorists'
Akiva Novick
Published: 18.06.12, 13:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
121 Talkbacks for this article
61. crazy
Tim ,   Holland   (06.18.12)
fundamentalist fight terrorist. Both crazy, and the world would be a better place without these psychos
62. "Jewish youth, learn to shoot!"
Max Merbaum ,   Los Angeles   (06.18.12)
"Jewish youth, learn to shoot!" -Ze'ev Jabotinsky. Shooting is like playing the violin, the Masters start at an early age.
63. THIS IS SICK!
marta ,   brazil   (06.18.12)
How not to solve a conflict being humans.
64. #31, where does it say all Palestinians are terrorists?
Avi   (06.18.12)
This activity is a simulation of killing inhuman terrorists like Samir Quntar. Not all Palestinians are terrorists, not all terrorists are Palestinians. So what does really abhor you? You claim to be from the UK yet you don't have basic reading skills.
65. SHAME ON ALL YOU SETTLERS
nancy tamir ,   caesarea, isrAEL   (06.18.12)
You talk about values? Please keep your American Jewish tourist children and their worthless parents out of our loving country. Go join the Arabs in their so-called summer camps for youngsters. And you, the settlers who are so 'miss-understood' by us Israelies, what the hell are you encouraging youngsters to use a gun. Our Israeli children learn to swim, play basketball etc., at their summer camps. So sad and disgusting.
66. learning to shoot
david ,   Raanana Israel   (06.18.12)
16/6/12 I have just read todays Yediot. Please refer to pp 18-19 and the article by a thoughtless, if not stupid reporter called AKIVA NOVIK [ and I think I shall include the editor as well ] on how certain Jewish persons are showing young children in the Gush how to use guns Only 2-3 weks ago we had the regular complaint against the Gazan childrens summer schools teaching their tiny tots to be good shaheedim with army uniform and guns.And we know these kids are brainwashed! Why o-why if we have some idiot on our side doing something similar must it take up a 2 page spread ? How can I plead pro Israel advocacy with such articles in a prime Israeli newspaper? Why indeed publish it? Sometimes an occasional 'truth' creates more harm than the other side
67. Disappointed
Masha ,   Chicago   (06.18.12)
Learning to shoot should never be advertised as a game. It is not. I used to admire (and still do) Israelis, including settlers, when I witnessed their mature attitude to war. You can, in fact, you MUST learn how to shoot, and even how to kill. But this is not an excuse for becoming cynical. It is a sad reality of life, not a game.
68. Cynical teachers? or writers?
Masha ,   Chicago, IL   (06.18.12)
Someone could have chosen to write about it differently. I do wonder how the organizers of the shooting range feel about this article. The authors make it sound like a cynical enterprise... but it is not. I wonder how much this is true class on self defence. The reason that it is in the West Bank, where the mere presence of the Jews is challenged by the whole world is probably adding into the appreciation of impotance. But, sure, it does sound cynical and almost evil on the surface.... It is all about how one puts it.. I tell you this: I would TAKE the class, I would appreciate what I learned, I would even rejoice that others had learned the importance of self defence with me.... However, I would remember that it is sad, that it is not ideal, that I must do everything I can to prevent having to use the skill....
69. who to blame.
db ,   montreal, ca   (06.18.12)
THE PARENTS THAT BRING THEIR KIDS. the guy is not saying we encourage kids to come and teach our own... if you noticed it was americans that were going there with their children. theyre just out to make a buck with what they know. not handing their kids an ak47.
70. Israelis must stay ready all the time
Pedro ,   Brazil   (06.18.12)
71. #60 Eaglebeak
Scott ,   Tallahassee   (06.19.12)
The little girls and teens who come from Miami don't have to worry about that either! You are blind.
72. Genocide adventure camp
Robert Rands ,   Hobart, Australia   (06.19.12)
As Rogers and Hammerstein wrote, in lyrics for South Pacific, "You've got to be carefully taught"
73. Tourists Shoot Terrorists
Kevin Barrington ,   Dublin Ireland   (06.19.12)
Jeiwish - fundamentalists teach children bigotry, murder and terror. No surprise there - same as all fundamentalists.
74. Complete hypocracy of Ynet!!!!
(06.19.12)
A few days ago, a number of articles flooded Ynet describing Gaza kids as monsters want to kill Jews and accusing Hamas of abusing kids in their struggle.......NOW what do you call this?!! Israeli kids are training to kill Gaza terrorist kids or what? I do not get it!!!! This is conflict between 2 peoples and each have a legitimate right to exist, but to use and abuse kids in any form or shape in this conflict is really disgusting and sickening!!! enough hypocracy and bias!!! Kids in Gaza deserve a better life and have no guilt to be punished by terrorist states like Israel. Publish if you dare.
75. #4
Thr truth ,   Israel   (06.19.12)
America has a lot of gun ranges... but imagine if a gun range had posters of blacks and hispanics, while the instructors told them to shoot the criminals. Yea, there would be chaos, like the LA riots back in the day.
76. Double Standards for Hypocrites
Koose E Mack ,   NY NY   (06.19.12)
Why is it ok for Muslim Extremists to teach there kids from birth to hate Israel and Jews; but not ok to teach Israeli/Jewish youth how to defend itself? We don't teach murder, hatred, and love of death. We have weapons to defend ourselves, not to murder innocent men, women, and children. As many have stated before,"Take weapons away from the Hamas, Fatah, Hezbollah, and other Muslim extremist garbage, and you will have peace tomorrow. Take weapons away from Jews, and you will have a blood bath!
77. Biased, badly written article
Avner ,   Tel Aviv   (06.19.12)
Sensationalist and incompetent article, which tries to draw some kind of lesson from going to a shooting range. What's wrong with going to a shooting range?
78. Confused
Dr. Stephen Oswald ,   NY USA   (06.19.12)
Which Terrorist from which side....that was unclear in the article.
79. Don't mix things!
Daniel ,   Belgium   (06.19.12)
The shame is to systematically mix Arabs with terrorists, even if it's not completely wrong. When you see the Gaza camp, the goal is clear - teach kids to fight AND kill Jews. In Gush Etzion the goal is to teach people to protect themselves against TERRORISTS. Not Arabs, not Muslims, but terrorists! While the Gazan camp is clearly racist, the Israeli camp has nothing to do with racism, it's a simple touristic adventure camp with some basic defense training. It's completely obvious that even the left jerks think about Arabs when they hear the word "terrorist" (it's almost a synonym btw), but it's not even a form of racism since they are responsible of 90% of terrorist activity allover the World. However, no one talked about Arabs in this camp, so hide your pathological, masked leftish racism and sit on it, cause where Arabs live, it's getting unsafe. I would recomed this camp to the French commandos, who couldn't have mastered the young Muslim terrorist, Merah, who killed Jewish children in Nimes and who they said to be too violent... Poor things aren't used to get shot with AK's unlike Israeli and US forces, who are always prepared!
80. The time is fast approaching when every man, woman and child
Harry Wright ,   UK   (06.19.12)
will have to learn the basics of defence against terrorism. This is not only an Israel issue.
81. Sick to my stomach.
Jozi ,   U.S.   (06.19.12)
This makes me want to throw up. This is the effects of governments glorifying militarization.
82. To: No. 29
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.19.12)
Yes, I served in the IDF. As did my husband. We were both officers -- me, in the JAG unit, my husband as a battlefield surgeon. I'm sorry, did you have a point, little hovesh boy? What problem do you have with Jews defending themselves? The next time you feel inclined to crawl on your knees and beg the ersatz "Palestinians" for mercy, do so on your own, you pathetic excuse for a Jew.
83. To: No. 27
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.19.12)
But dressing up little ersatz "Palestinian" kindergarteners as terrorists or suicide bombers, and arming them with rifles doesn't qualify as sick to you? Do you have a problem with Jews defending themselves against terrorist scum? I guess you do. Why am I not surprised?
84. I'd like to know how many Jews in the USA
Al   (06.19.12)
actually own guns and know how to use them. I bet you very very few. The Israelis are providing a fantasy to these wannabe warriors. The proof is in the pudding, either the American Jews start owning guns and learn how to use them or they will end up as history. America is descending into class warfare and the Jews, the 1% will end up being the korban. Of course the Jews of America are too stupid to realize that. They will still run I say run to re-elect Obama who in his second term will turn on the Jews of Israel and indeed America with a vengance.
85. This picture
BK ,   US   (06.19.12)
It infuriates me to see pictures of Palestinian kids with guns, learning to kill Jews. The picture of this beautiful girl with a gun is very upsetting as well--what's good for the goose, is also good for the gander.
86. Give pathetic leftists much more to get upset about.
Chaim ,   Israel   (06.19.12)
It's easy to understand why far leftists like Avramele are repelled by the glorious spirit of strength and self respect. Nothing upsets an Israeli leftist more than Jews who fight to win. Jews who won't concede. These Judea and Samaria residents, and visiting tourists, have the right idea. We need to give these pathetic leftists much more to get upset about.
87. Defund Jewish Terror Cells
Golden Dome ,   Washington, USA   (06.19.12)
U.S. Congress should put this on their Adelson sponsored tour.
88. #30 - Jews lived in Gush Etzion before State founded
Moshe Tokayer ,   Petach Tikvah, Israe   (06.19.12)
Learn some history. The only difference between Gush Etzion and any part of "Israel proper" is that we were illegally thrown out of Gush Etzion in 1949. Other than that there's no differrence between Gush Etzion and Tel Aviv.
89. there is a moral differance if the target is a terrorist
mosh ,   israel   (06.19.12)
who's targeting at you, or a innocent israeli citizen. targeting soldiers is morel, targeting citizens is not.
90. training terror!
Zico ,   Hague   (06.19.12)
Article 29 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child: 1. States Parties agree that the education of the child shall be directed to: (a) The development of the child's personality, talents and mental and physical abilities to their fullest potential; (b) The development of respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms, and for the principles enshrined in the Charter of the United Nations; (c) The development of respect for the child's parents, his or her own cultural identity, language and values, for the national values of the country in which the child is living, the country from which he or she may originate, and for civilizations different from his or her own; (d) The preparation of the child for responsible life in a free society, in the spirit of understanding, peace, tolerance, equality of sexes, and friendship among all peoples, ethnic, national and religious groups and persons of indigenous origin; (e) The development of respect for the natural environment. 2. No part of the present article or article 28 shall be construed so as to interfere with the liberty of individuals and bodies to establish and direct educational institutions, subject always to the observance of the principle set forth in paragraph 1 of the present article and to the requirements that the education given in such institutions shall conform to such minimum standards as may be laid down by the State.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article