News
Kerry: US views all settlements as illegitimate
Ynet
Published: 12.08.13, 19:20
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
107 Talkbacks for this article
61. May Kerry and Company be irked and
Israeli 2   (08.13.13)
remain irked for ever and ever - Amen!
62. I am sick and tired
Gershon ,   London   (08.13.13)
of the world's hypocritical self righteous diplomats pronouncing the settlements illegal and illegitamate. what sickens me more is Israel's silence in the face of such criticism which implies agreement with it!! Why doesnt Netanyahu and his government have the guts (and brains) to tell the truth to the world that: sorry chaps this land is OUR land (vive Woodie Guthrie!) and has been since God gave it to us over 3500 years ago. No amount of your pompous arrogant diplomatic pronouncements on the legality or legitimacy of towns/ villages built on our land have any value whatsoever, so you may as well save your breath. we aint leaving our land - ever! end of story.
63. Construction hurts the US ! Just too
DT ,   TA Israel   (08.13.13)
darn bad and just as is their exercise in futility of their inititaing "peace" talks.
64. Thank you Sarah B.
Gilda COhen ,   Rome   (08.13.13)
I can see you changed your views. That is good. It means you have done your homework properly. Yes, dear, I agree with you. The days of the settlement entreprize are coming to an end. The pictures of women crying and screaming will be back and the trauma will be huge. The Government should be by now avoiding all this, but instead it has been building more settlements. They will last something like two, three months. Sarah B, again, welcome to the side of enlightenment and rational Zionism.
65. NO USA
Lev Orgon ,   Beit Shemesh   (08.13.13)
USA is not our friend. We have to look for good and friend countries like China, India and Russia. The USA has been a big burden for us. GET OUT USA, LEAVE US ALONE. The land of Israel will be ours forever. And we will rebuild the great Jewish empire from Syria to Jordan again with the help of Him.
66. #64 You represent Rome well!
David ,   Shiloh Israel   (08.13.13)
67. Doesnt look good
EU ,   USA Transelvania   (08.13.13)
It doesnt look good for Israel right now. Its like a mental chess match now. If Israel were to back out of the talks now because of the EU ban and the Palestinians were to remain in the talks despite the so called illegal settlement building it would upset and infuriate the whole international community. They would say hey Israel youre building these illegal settlements and the Palestinians are still willing to talk peace but now you want to back out due to the EU ban? If Palestine backs now its because Israel refuses to stop building Settlements. The whole world is telling Israel to stop and they are being defiant. Either way Israel faces a slew of International isolation. #1. Palestine might get full recognition at the UN for a member state state. #2. The EU ban will remain in place #3. The PA will take Israel to the world court for war crimes. #4. The UN might dish out sanctions. Who knows what else? War? PA unites with Hamas! More rockets fired into Israel.
68. #34 All Jews are settlers in Israel
David ,   Shiloh Israel   (08.13.13)
I know you're writing under an assumed name, no problems there. If you really claim to represent the 'rest' of the Jews in Israel, which I doubt, here's some advice...In the eyes of the majority of those you wish to appease at all cost, Israel is not regarded as the Jewish homeland, and Jews in every part of our beloved land are seen as intrusive settlers. I'm not against the left, the true left understood the settler mentality, and created our country based on building outposts and marking our borders accordingly. As for prisoner releases, you check the records yourself of the horrific crimes commited by those animals. There is 'no' justification for terrorism, whether from Jew, Arab, or anyone else. You're defending a dying cause...pun intended.
69. Move the talks to Eilat
Devorah   (08.13.13)
70. usa
AV ,   London .UK   (08.13.13)
sod the us
71. Settlements
Moses   (08.13.13)
Bloody Europeans know nothing but feel fine about lecturing Israel on what to do. Don't worry. Your time will come real soon.
72. # 62 - Same here cousin!
Palestinian ,   Palestine   (08.13.13)
73. (16) Gunnar
tiki ,   belgium   (08.13.13)
Your comments show that you haven't the slightest clue what you are talking about. How did the '''settlements''' came about? They came about when Jordan attacked Israel in 1967 (when this was land, illegally stolen from the Jews by the Brits and given to the Arabs in 1923). If the Jordanians wouldn't have attacked Israel, this whole area would still have been under Jordanian occupation, there would not be any ''discussion about a Palestinian state (because Jordan was/is Palestine) and Jews wouldn't even have the right to step into these old Jewish lands & heritage Because Jordan lost the annihilation war they started, Israel reclaimed what was hers for thousands of years and started building houses for Jews.
74. US "views settlements as illegal
tiki ,   belgium   (08.13.13)
Well, that's fine but Israel "views things differently. Israel "views that historic Jewish Judea & Samaria & 'East'Jerusalem were stolen lands. Stolen from the Jews by different occupiers and rightfully re-owned in 1967! All the rest are lies & manipulations about Jewish history & heritage! Only when the lies will stop, a deal can be made!
75. Chaim 54 . more than thousand lawyers ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (08.13.13)
Who did they represent ? Where and when did they proclaim this ? But most of UN countries oppose it . And they have more power than your "lawyers" . Now i agree that we must , i say MUST , build in Yeroushalaim , Ariel , The Etzion bloc and other big Jewish towns . What will you do with the inhabitants of Ramallah , Shechem , Bethlehem , and other such places ? Deport them in cattle trains ?
76. 68, David
(08.13.13)
She is a fake and she definitely does not represent Jews in Israel.
77. Who is this Kerry, and why do his views interest us?!
Kishta!   (08.13.13)
78. According to which law?
Andrew Brehm ,   Zurich   (08.13.13)
They keep repeating that the "settlements" are "illegal", but they never mention according to which law they are. The reason is simple, they don't know which law they could use. Annexing land won in a war is not and never was illegal, as Hawaii-born President Obama can confirm and as any Russian in Kaliningrad can swear. The simple fact of the matter is that the only thing the Palestinians have to offer is peace and they already owed Israel peace ever since before the war began. They have nothing to give but expect to get a lot. If the world decides to punish Israel because Israel violated a law; a law that exists written somewhere and that other countries are also punished for violating, then I'm game. But if the world decides to punish Israel because Israel does not do what the world wants, I'll stand with the "settlers". Whenever the world wanted something and the Jews, any Jews, just submitted to others' will, Jews (and ultimately the whole world) suffered for it. If John Kerry is convinced that settling land won in a war is illegal, he can clean up the American mess in Hawaii first. No Israeli will try to stop him. But it's not about "illegal settlements", it's about Jewish such. If the settlements are American, Chinese, Russian or Arab, they are FINE.
79. Tiki , 74 . I agree
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (08.13.13)
But what will you do with the "palestinians" who live there ? Send them to a "kazerne dossin" in order to deport them in cattle trains as our parents and grandparents were ? Who will accept them ? The whole world will oppose this , and that's not "historiccal rights" , it's "2013 REALITY"
80. Crickets chirping in regards to "right of return"
Logic ,   Israel   (08.13.13)
I think I've heard this administration condemn the settlements hundreds of times already, but I haven't heard even once that the crux of the conflict - the so-called "Palestinian right of return" - is illegitimate!
81. #34
Allan ,   Johannesburg. South   (08.13.13)
Your point Sarah, that it is ok that the Pals released tonight killed only adults. Your mind is warped. It is about time that Israel does what it has always done.. Stand on her own. What back-stabbing from Kerry. As a negotiator for peace talks he is anything but, and just a mouth-piece for Obama's love of Islam.
82. Obama a friend of Israel?
michael Pielet ,   israel   (08.13.13)
Obama is illegitimate and so is Kerry. Obama is an isolationist and Islamist.
83. The settlements and terrorists
Rhonda ,   Chicago, USA   (08.13.13)
Funny how they are all wound up about the settlements but don't seem to be handwringing about the release of terrorists...
84. To: Charles at No. 75
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (08.13.13)
What we do is to send them in airplanes or buses or whatever. They are Jordanian citizens, courtesy of Jordan's 1954 Citizenship Law. They aren't being deported. They are being repatriated. Major legal difference.
85. who cares what obama and kerry the terrorist supporters VIEW
Father Abe   (08.13.13)
86. Close to my opinion of...
Gideon Reader   (08.13.13)
John Effen Kerry. I have always thought of him as an illegitimate bugger. Particularly when he is throwing someone else's medals away or sitting with the declared at war enemy of his country. There is always more than a whiff of treason fueled by a sense of entitlement and overt greed wafting around this gigglio. To M. Kerry who sailed where there was no water; whose "magic hat" comforted him, ...A burnt toast...May your days be long. And painful.
87. As is any US building in Texas
Larry ,   Or Yehuda   (08.13.13)
88. kerry's prejudice
martin ,   uk   (08.13.13)
so arabs can live anywhere in the world. however, only jews are told where they can, and in this case, cannot live. Egyptian born Palestinian abbas will not allow jews to live in Palestine. hello Kerry, where are your democratic fundamentals today? buried under all the arab oil money donated to your party? are they repaying back all the unaccounted $billions that have gone missing?
89. #24 Chris
Avi ,   Israel   (08.13.13)
She is not a fake Sarah, you dummy...She is another Sarah, that has honor and dignity...
90. US president Obama,the first illegitimate president of USA
Anna M sedda ,   Rome-Italy   (08.13.13)
I believe US president is the first and most illegimate President of USA; he run for presidency by deception and he is a Kenia citizen,not a US resident.For this reason,he legalized Palestine and he is always against Israel....US has became the country of deception,starting from his president...USA cannot be trusted anymore....
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article