Anti-refugee rally in Tel Aviv
Yaron Brenner
Fostering hate?
Photo: Yaron Brener

Report: Israel's treatment of asylum seekers lacking

US State Department's Human Rights Practices report for 2011 criticizes government mechanism as discriminatory; slams ministers' use of term 'infiltrators,' fostering of link between refugees and terror, crime

A United States State Department report reviewing the global situation of refugees and asylum seekers in 2011 describes Israel's treatment of African asylum seekers as "lacking."


The report, titled "Human Rights Practices for 2011," was released on Thursday. It deals with a series of criteria pertaining to asylum cases, such as legal status and the providing of shelter, employment and healthcare; and is based on data provided by NGOs and the United Nations Refugee Agency (UNHCR).


Related stories:


The report says that while Israel's laws "provide for the granting of temporary asylum and the government has established a system for providing temporary protection for most asylum seekers, there were complaints about the system’s accessibility and reports of discrimination."


The current laws, the report added, "Allow the Ministry of Interior to reject applications without appeal even at the registration stage, and exclude 'enemy nationals' from receiving asylum. The regulations fail to establish an independent appeal process."


מבקשי מקלט באשדוד. רק פליט אחד אושר ב-2011 (צילום: אליעד לוי)

Asylum seekers in Ashdod (Photo: Eliad Levy)


UNHCR data quoted by the State Department indicated that in 2011, 4,603 new asylum applications were filed; the government rejected 3,692 and approved one.


  • For the full report click here


The report further criticized the use of the term "infiltrators" by State officials: "Government officials often negatively referred to asylum seekers as 'infiltrators.'


"According to NGOs, officials periodically characterized asylum seekers as directly associated with rises in crime, disease, and terrorism."


The report also mentions an interview Interior Minister Eli Yishai gave Army Radio in December 2011, in which he said: "I will safeguard the Jewish majority of the state, and I ensure that the last of the Sudanese, and the Eritreans, and all of the infiltrators, to the last of them, will return to their countries."


Government promoting hate?

While "recognized refugees receive social services, including access to the national healthcare system," the report noted that the government does not provide asylum seekers with public social benefits such as health insurance.


The report does, however, mention that in 2011 Israel granted temporary protection to refugees, primarily to Eritrean and Sudanese asylum seekers, and at times to asylum seekers from the Democratic Republic of Congo, Ivory Coast, and Somalia.


Physicians for Human Rights commented on the report's findings, saying that "Sans proper protection and in preventing access to basic services like healthcare and equal opportunity-employment, Israel has become an ugly example for the treatment of asylum seekers.


"Statements like those made by Minister Yishai, which are quoted in the report, only go to demonstrate how busy the Israeli government is with siccing various groups against each other, instead of formulating responsible policies," the statement said.


"We remind the prime minister and the government that they are responsible. The prime minister must make the brave decision to adopt a policy of social residency, which will provide asylum seekers with temporary protection and a dignified existence, pending the decision on their cases."



  • Receive Ynetnews updates directly to your desktop


פרסום ראשון: 05.24.12, 22:50
 new comment
This will delete your current comment