Photo: AFP
PM Netanyahu
Photo: AFP

Facing backlash, PM Netanyahu reneges on Israel-UN deal on asylum seekers

Meeting considerable opposition from coalition allies, voter base, PM Netanyahu acquiesces to demands that he suspend deal reached with UN on deportation of African immigrants, says he will reexamine it.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announced Monday night that he is suspending the implementation of the plan reached with the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) on the deportation of African immigrants, just hours after announcing that he had approved it.



Israel reached an agreement with the UNHCR to resolve the African migrants crisis, nixing the government's controversial mass deportation plan and agreeing to grant temporary legal status to protected populations among the asylum seekers, some 18,000 refugees who would've remained in the country regardless.


PM Netanyahu (Photo: AFP)
PM Netanyahu (Photo: AFP)


In a post he wrote in his Facebook account, the premier explained that "in the last few weeks, following tremendous pressure on Rwanda by the New Israel Fund and elements in the European Union, Rwanda has withdrawn from the agreement and refused to absorb infiltrators from Israel who are forcibly removed. As a result, I decided to strive for a new agreement that would allow us to continue deporting the infiltrators.


"However, I am attentive to you, and first and foremost to the residents of southern Tel Aviv," Netanyahu reassured. "Therefore, I decided to meet, together with Interior Minister Aryeh Deri, with representatives of the residents of southern Tel Aviv tomorrow (Wednesday) morning.


"In the meantime, I am suspending the implementation of the agreement, and after I meet with the representatives, I will bring the agreement for a new examination."


Earlier on Monday, Netanyahu announced in a press conference the "landmark achievement," saying it will see 16,250 asylum seekers out of the country, taken to "developed countries like Canada, or Germany and Italy" as part of a measure the UNHCR has committed to organize "and even fund."


While the UNHCR confirmed an agreement was signed with Israel, it did not name the countries that would accept the migrants, and some of the countries mentioned by Netanyahu deny any such agreement was signed with them.


A spokesman for the German Interior Ministry said he was unaware of any plans to resettle African migrants from Israel to Germany. In Italy, a Foreign Ministry source said: "There is no agreement with Italy in the context of the bilateral agreement between Israel and the UNHCR."


Shortly after Italy's denial, the PMO issued a statement to Italian news agency ANSA, clarifying that Netanyahu only named Italy as an example of a developed Western country, and did not specifically mean to name it as one of the countries willing to take in the asylum seekers, Italian daily la Repubblica reported


Asylum seekers celebrating the agreement in south Tel Aviv, minutes before it was suspended (Photo: Yariv Katz)
Asylum seekers celebrating the agreement in south Tel Aviv, minutes before it was suspended (Photo: Yariv Katz)


Netanyahu added that the agreement with the UN, as it currently stands, came following strenuous political efforts on their part, noting that at first the UN wanted Israel to keep four asylum seekers as temporary residents for every one deported.


"We did not agree to this, and in the end reached an agreement whereby for each one that leaves, one will remain," he said.


Netanyahu concluded by stressing that while he, like many others, expected Israel to be able to deport the lot of them, once it was clear it is not an option, the government decided to "do the best it can—get some out, rehabilitate the rest and rehabilitate south Tel Aviv."


Later that evening, Netanyahu published a video on Facebook in which he gave further details on the outline.


"We will remove the infiltrators from south Tel Aviv, bring them to moshavim, kibbutzim, and strong communities, so that the burden will not fall on neighborhoods in distress," he said. "The money we'll save, and that's a lot, we'll invest in rehabilitating southern Tel Aviv."


He then noted that the new agreement will see 2,000 more immigrants deported from the state compared to the previous plan, and that "those who will stay, will remain here temporarily for the next five years."


Coalition, voters turn on PM, urge him to rethink

The fate of some 37,000 Africans in Israel has posed a moral dilemma for a state founded as a haven for Jews from persecution and as a national home. The right-wing government has been under pressure from its nationalist voter base to expel the migrants, who are believed to be economic migrants rather than refugees.


But the planned mass deportation led to legal challenges in Israel, drew criticism from the United Nations and rights groups and triggered an emotional public debate among Israelis.


Anti-expulsion rally (Photo: Eli Mendelbaum)
Anti-expulsion rally (Photo: Eli Mendelbaum)


While receiving the support of more left-leaning organizations and lawmakers, many nationalists and conservatives, including some from Netanyahu's own Likud party, expressed strong objection to the agreement, claiming it will encourage illegal immigration which would further exasperate the crisis.


Minister of Education and Beyit Yehudi leader Naftali Bennett said the agreement to grant legal status to thousands of 'infiltrators' will "turn Israel into a paradise for infiltrators, and constitutes a total surrender to the false campaign that has been disseminated in the media in recent months."


He added that "by signing this agreement, we are sending a dangerous message to the entire world: 'Anyone who succeeds in infiltrating Israel illegally will receive a residency award here or in a Western country.'"


"These are not the results we expected," lamented Transportation Minister Yisrael Katz. "The good of the residents of south Tel Aviv and the rest of the citizens of Israel must be first and foremost. The government's policy, as determined, is not to allow anyone who is not recognized as a refugee to remain in Israel, and any arrangement that is made must be within the framework of this policy."


Katz noted that "the consent of various countries to absorb some of the infiltrators into Israel should be welcomed, but not conditioned on an Israeli commitment to grant legal residency status."

Education Minister Bennett (L) and Transportation Minister Katz (Photo: Alex Kolomoisky)
Education Minister Bennett (L) and Transportation Minister Katz (Photo: Alex Kolomoisky)


Minister of Finance Moshe Kahlon called the proposed outline "insufficient," saying the number of infiltrators who will receive the status of temporary residence is "large and unacceptable."


Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked stressed the agreement needs to be brought to the Knesset for examination and approval, saying that "the State of Israel does not have to accept the presence of infiltrators who entered here illegally."


MK Oren Hazan also criticized Netanyahu, fuming over the agreement giving the migrants residency in Israel.


"The government is now trying to explain its capitulation on the infiltrators with flowery words that have no practical significance," he said. "The bottom line: a bit of public pressure and this 'strong' government simply folded. It would really be funny if it was not such a serious and painful subject."


Even Culture and Sports Minister Miri Regev—a close ally of Netanyahu—criticized the agreement.


"The decision that was announced today is dramatic and I am definitely concerned about the quick concession of the basic principles of the government's immigration policy," she said. "As far as we know, these are not refugees, but people who have infiltrated (the country) illegally, so the discussions with the UN High Commissioner for Refugees, in my view, are out of place.


"The final result, according to which tens of thousands of infiltrators remain in Israel, is very worrying in terms of the identity of the state and its social fabric," Regev added, saying the plan to relocate them is faulty, as they will not end up living in "strong communities," as Netanyahu said, but in "the periphery," where they "will cause great damage, as is the case in south Tel Aviv."


Justice Minister Shaked (L) and Culture and Sports Minister Regev (Photo: Alex Kolomoisky, Ohad Zwigenberg)
Justice Minister Shaked (L) and Culture and Sports Minister Regev (Photo: Alex Kolomoisky, Ohad Zwigenberg)


The premier was also attacked on social media, with people—ostensibly his voters—saying his "spineless" capitulation only proved "the High Court of Justice is the actual body running the country," and that he has lost their support. Last month, the High Court issued a temporary injunction for the state, ordering it to halt the mass expulsion until it submits a response to a petition made to the court against it. The state now has one week to reply, but the Passover holiday hiatus may make it difficult to formulate a policy on time.


Left-wing politicians, though, spoke in a different tone, wholeheartedly welcoming the agreement.


Chairman of the Zionist Union Party Avi Gabbay praised the new agreement. "After years of ignoring the problem, there is finally an outline that also recognizes their status as asylum seekers. It also lays down a solution for the rehabilitation of the neighborhoods of southern Tel Aviv and also establishes a policy for migrant workers," he said.


The social-democratic Meretz party issued a statement saying the agreement, in effect, means the word 'infiltrators' they say is used to vilify asylum seekers is being "removed from the lexicon" following a victorious public battle for a "just and fair solution" to the refugee crisis.


Nevertheless, the party reiterated their stance that "Israel should examine each asylum request and provide protection for refugees on par with Western standards," saying that the solution to keep half and deport the rest is not optimal, as "refugees are not baked goods that can simply be cut in half."


As Netanyahu U-turns, so do critics

Following Netanyahu's backtracking on the UN agreement, many on the Right breathed a sigh of relief, while left-wing politicians and citizens supporting the migrants were caught off guard and left deflated..


Regev congratulated the prime minister for his "leadership and attentiveness to the voice of the general public in Israel," adding that "the State of Israel, as a Jewish and democratic state, must adhere to its immigration policy and strictly conserve its identity and social fabric. Illegal labor infiltrators must return to their countries of origin."


Bennett praised Netanyahu's decision to suspend the "bad" agreement, adding, "It is not enough. Now we need to get the infiltrators out of the country."


Gabbay called Netanyahu's backpedal "sad, embarrassing and especially disturbing," taking the opportunity to berate him on recent security issues, like the unrest on the Gaza border, saying, "We have no reason to assume that in matters of security, the prime minister's decision-making process is any better."


Amir Alon, Shahar Hay, Adi Rozenberg, Moran Azulay and Lior Mor contributed to this report.


פרסום ראשון: 04.02.18, 23:44
 new comment
This will delete your current comment