News
61 percent of Brits: Israel overreacting
Ynet
Published: 25.07.06, 10:55
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
129 Talkbacks for this article
61. Faith , Israel : hatred
Ana M. ,   Spain   (07.25.06)
I am Spanish and love Israel. There are many more people like me here. Although I know you have reasons to think like that, "thanks" to our idiotic dis-government, which makes a lot of people here ashamed. If this is useful for something, I can tell you that most newspapers are criticising what the disgovernment is doing. Shalom
62. An astonishing letter in today's Times
Larry ,   Eastbourne, UK   (07.25.06)
Here are some extracts from a letter in The Times today that illustrate perfectly how some Britons have got it completely wrong, either wilfully or as a result of media failure to report the Israeli catastrophe. "...the rocket attacks on Israel.....are little more than nuisance raids. The Israeli infrastucture has not been damaged...........Some 500,000 Lebanese have been forced to leave their homes...........No such evacuation has been necessary in Israel." All lies, utterly wicked lies.
63. 47 Rustumtum The Vile Islamic Extremist still talking Crap
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (07.25.06)
one of these days the Yard is going to knock on his front door They use the Carnivore system to catch this fool
64. Guardian
BS meter ,   Canada   (07.25.06)
I'd like to see the questions the Guardian posed. You can do a lot of spin that way, e.g., "Do you think the indisciminate killing of Lebanese women and children is a proportionate or disproportionate response to the kidnapping of two soldiers," vs. "Do you think the assault on HEzbollah strongholds is a prop or disprop response to their existential threats to Israel?" The Guardian is so predictable. Anyway, I'm actually surprised at the numbers here. I would have thought they were much more anti-Israeli and anti-American (in Iraq) than they actually appear to be.
65. #58 and #62
BS meter ,   Canada   (07.25.06)
Andrew -- Those are fantastics pics. They should be viewed by everybody, alongside the transcript of a rally held by, I think, al-Sadr. It reads like a plagiarism of the Nuremberg rally. Larry -- It's been the same here in Canada. I haven't seen anywhere about 1million Israelis living in bomb shelters, etc. As for infrastructure and "collective punsihment," I did here a radio interview yesterday with Lebanon's former Minister of the Economy. He said the costs were huge, but the destruction was narrowly contained in Hezbollah strongholds.
66. 1947
gil ,   ashkelon   (07.25.06)
Remember how nice were the Brits toward "civilian" trying to make their way to Eretz,? From Laurence to Glubb they have always sided by their beloved friends.
67. Most Brits are not interested
S Judah ,   london   (07.25.06)
This is from a Guardian Poll - The most anti Israel paper about and reflects the News which lingers on Lebanese Civilian causality and does not explain the fight against terror or Hezballah hiding amongst the civilians.
68. 63% of british are anti sematic
Yohan ,   Amsterdam   (07.25.06)
that will be the firts respond by the Israeli leaders. Israel: Wake up
69. PLO REWARDED for JIHAD AGAINST LEBANON'S CHRISTIANS
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (07.25.06)
Lebanon was a Christian country until Muslims achieved a majority through an extremely high birthrate. The jihad against Lebanon's Christians was savage and barbaric. The IDF was the only hope for the embattled Christians. Click on Photo gallery: http://www.free-lebanon.com/ 20,000 Christians handicapped by PLO atrocities. PLO terrorists were rewarded for their savagery and mass murder of Christians by implanting them into Israel as TERRORIST "peace" partners through Oslo to continue the bloody, barbaric jihad. The Christians of Damour, Lebanon treated Muslims from surrounding areas free of charge in their hospital. The PLO and other terrorists repaid the Christian kindness with barbaric savagery: The Massacre and Destruction of Damour 'The attack took place from the mountain behind. It was an apocalypse. They were coming, thousands and thousands, shouting 'Allahu Akbar! God is great! Let us attack them for the Arabs, let us offer a holocaust to Mohammad 'And they were slaughtering everyone in their path, men, women and children.' Whole families were killed in their homes. Many women were gang-raped..." http://www.free-lebanon.com/LFPNews/psa/psa.html Satanic acts were perpetrated on Damour Christians.
70. #63 threatening and offensive. please remove
Rustum ,   London, UK   (07.25.06)
How dare you threaten me. How dare you constantly post vile racist remarks. How dare you constantly refer to a preacher of non-violence as "vile Islamic Extremist" And why exactly is it that you don't live in Israel?
71. Larry , Eastbourne, UK
Gregg Smith ,   Durham, Uk   (07.25.06)
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA who wrote that. The Independant is as bad as the rest, heres a hint Don't read to deeply into what the BBC and the newspapers say over here especially what these so called polls state they are nearly always wrong, If you trust polls trust the papers like the Sun they are more for everyday people whereas the Times independant are for the so called Intellectuals. The BBC has started to show it's bias alot more in recent days just look at the main page for the middle east crisis, they're accusing Israel of using Human shields in Gaza now. What they haven't reported on is the Pro Israel rallies that have been held throughout the country but the Anti- Israel rallies get the attention.
72. The record of Brit press on ANY issue
Steve G ,   Kew Gardens,NYC   (07.25.06)
If you follow the British press, you will see that they can't get anything right on any issue or government, even their own. They got bogged down in factionalism, distortion, false reporting and agenda-flogging a long, long time ago. Facing the reality of British 'reporting' is important. I believe that if Israel had more large-breasted women soldiers in skimpy uniforms, the British press coverage would be much more favorable.
73. # 61 - Ana
Faith ,   Israel   (07.25.06)
Thank you for being so brave and actually saying you support Israel. If your government makes you feel ashamed, and gives us the wrong impression, why don't you people do something about it then? Just sitting back and quietly letting them have their say (in your country's name) is being passive. And we all know where that led in World War II. Meanwhile, it is still good to know that not all the world has lost it's mind, and there are sane people. But...I still will not give any of my money to the countries I listed in my previous talkback, and I will encourage others to do likewise. Europe has become a terrorist haven. Scary.
74. Complaint about #63
Rustum ,   London, Uk   (07.25.06)
What is it about you that you do not allow people to voice their opinions? How is it that you manage to turn every statement in favour of peace into a personal attack, an attack on peoples' physiognomies? How is it that you never address any issue but simply turn peoples' opinions inside out and then slap on them your usual "anti-Semite" label? It seems to me that your level of debate is somewhat similar to that of Berio and Stalin. You obviously have not got the intelligence to answer any single question - but you exist on the level of a Wizo coffee morning "oh, isn't it terrible, oh aren't they awful, oh aren't the Moslems bad people" I believe in the Uk we call this "fishwifery." However, I would be more than obliged if you refrain from threatening me personally. If you believe I have said anything that is against British law - then kindly state so. Your vile statement that "one of these days the yard is going to knock on his front door" is odious in the extreme and implies that I have done something illegal. If expressing a non-violent opinion is an illegal in the UK, you might care to state what law it contravenes. We are not living in 1930s Germany now - although I believe your brain is still there - and freedom of thought, freedom of expression are all guaranteed - in the UK and even in Israel. In other words, Ms Goldwater - refrain from your foul threats against me personally.
75. 61% of Brits....
Jack Cohen ,   San Diego, USA   (07.25.06)
Israel should take no heed to any poll regarding Israel or the Jewish people. Nowadays, a poll in England or anywhere in Europe for that matter, might as well be taken in downtown Islamabad.
76. Let the Northern Irish Bomb England
Rob ,   US NJ   (07.25.06)
Who needs Leeds, Manchester, etc. Let the bloody jackasses take it. See how long the British will sit quiet before their army would go into Northern Ireland. What a bunch of morons.
77. #68, Yohan
BS meter ,   Canada   (07.25.06)
Actually, the first thing that came to my mind was another recent poll: - Britain is the European country where non-Muslims think best of Muslims - Britain is the European country where Muslims think worst of non-Muslims You guys are pathetically deluded.
78. the poll doesn't represent the views of everyone
danielle ,   oxford, britain   (07.25.06)
Sadly it is the case that there is a portion of the British population that seems to think it is fashionable at the moment to speak out against the British, the American, and the Israeli governments...without actually taking the time to understand what they are speaking out against... But I just thought I should make something clear....the fact that 61% of those who voted in the poll were against Israel's actions does not mean that 61% of the British public holds such views. The people who voted in the poll would only have been people who read The Guardian (which is mostly students and so-called 'intellectuals') and that certainly is not the entire population of the country. You'll probably find that 61% of the country did not even vote in the poll. I certainly didn't.
79. Guardian UK
David ,   Freehold NJ USA   (07.25.06)
I'm not surprised by this poll , The Gurdian is the Most Anti- Semitic newspaper in the UK . I'm surprised they did not inflate these figures to 100%
80. Israel & Hezbollah
Benjamin Rhoads ,   Leonardtown Maryland   (07.25.06)
It is really too bad that the rest of the country of Lenanon must suffer right along with the Hezbollah...But everyone pretty much knew that this was bound to happen between the Hezbollah and the Israelis...I believe Israel has every right to defend itself and inflict great harm on its adversaries that transgress on it borders and try to take its soldiers prisoner and also kill them as well...They are definately not overreacting....If I were surrounded by enemies all around I would not hold back at all either and I am quite certain Great Britan would not either under similar circumstances...
81. So, UK overreacted in WW2??
Gal   (07.25.06)
I mean, there was no German force on their soil, why demolish so many German cities over a few U2 missiles?
82. To No. 17, Robert
NYC Girl   (07.25.06)
Of course the Falklands wasn't an overreaction. After all, you never know when those penguins might turn on you.
83. not very accurate
Jennifer ,   Tel Aviv   (07.25.06)
shouldn't they make it more clear that 61% of 1001 people said that - what about the other 60 million? They probably only asked people who live in tower hamlets.
84. Islamic Republic of England
Marc ,   London England   (07.25.06)
Dar Al HArb. England is next.
85. 61% of Brits are waiting....
Survivor ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.25.06)
The Brits only hear SKY, BBC or CNN and on those stations the only 'human tragedies' are only in Gaza, Judea and Samaria and Lebanon. The never heard of Darfur or Rwanda. Before the last election one Muslim leader declared that 'soon the flag of Islam will fly over No.10' and so these newsreaders as well as the 300 Jews in the Time advert are preparing for that day. No doubt the female newsreaders will look somewhat less attractive in the Chador and other Muslim women accoutrements they will then have to wear.
86. To #23 and Rustum
Mark ,   USA   (07.25.06)
I proudly boycott the United Kingdom. The BBC America is British Anti-Semitism. The UK caused this problem by giving Palestinian land to a made up kingdom called Jordan. They are 100% responsible for the Arab/Israeli conflict and need to take full responsibility for this crisis.
87. To Rustum
Allan ,   london   (07.25.06)
Rustum, Actually Israel is well within its legal right to kick Arab MK's who support and praise Hizbollah and Hamas, as that is called being a traitor and consorting with enemies of the state., Exactly the same as that vile toad George Galloway. But then I am sure you will pick some fault with this and call me a Nazi.. But then the British goverment rounded up enough Nazi sympathisers during the war. Its a shame they wont to do the same now to all the muslims in the UK. who identify with Bin Laden and approve of suicide bombing in England. Being a londoner you should know this. But then you views probably mean you are an Arab and as such, please leave England as you are occupying Christian lands.
88. Antisemites and termites
C'est Moi ,   Canada   (07.25.06)
Headlines by self-indulgent zionists...."That's because 61% of Brits are anti-semitics and they belong to Eurabia and they are jihadists" Oooh PLEASE
89. Jacques in Belgium
Floyd   (07.25.06)
"You can fool some people some of the time, but not all people all of the Time!!!" Really? Hezballah is fooling you all of the time and you being the sucker that you are..have fallen for it hook, line and sinker. How does it feel to be Hezballah's bitch?
90. Who reads the Guardian anyway?
Nannette ,   London, UK   (07.25.06)
It's the mouthpiece for terrorists and the extreme, antisemitic left.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article