Illustration
Photo: Visual/Photos
US: Boy can make circumcision decision
Divorced parents fight over child's circumcision. Judge decides: Boy can decide for himself about circumcision when he turns 18
A judge in Chicago has sided with a divorced father who did not want his 9-year-old son circumcised, in a case that has drawn attention from groups opposed to the surgical procedure.
Cook County Circuit Judge Jordan Kaplan's ruling, issued Tuesday, said the boy can decide for himself about circumcision when he turns 18. Until then, there will be no circumcision, a surgery that removes the foreskin of the penis.
The Associated Press is not naming the parents to protect the child's privacy. The father was born and raised in Poland; the mother is from Slovakia. Both now live in suburban Chicago.
A 2003 divorce decree gave the boy's father the right to offer advice on medical decisions.
The father opposed circumcision because he believed it could cause his son long-term physical and psychological harm. The child's mother wanted the procedure done to prevent recurring infections.
When the two could not resolve their dispute, the father sued to block the circumcision.
In his ruling, Kaplan called circumcision "an extraordinary medical procedure as it relates to a nine-year-old child."
Alan Toback, the father's attorney, said his client is extremely happy with the judge's decision and feels he saved part of his son's anatomy.
Medical necessity of circumcision
A telephone call from The Associated Press to the mother's attorney on Tuesday was not immediately returned. The mother had testified that her son suffered five bouts of painful inflammation and had begged her to help him.
The case reflects a national debate over the medical necessity of circumcision. In 1999, the American Academy of Pediatrics reversed its support of routine infant circumcision, citing questionable benefits and medical and anecdotal evidence that circumcised men have less penile sensitivity.
Most U.S. newborn boys are circumcised before they leave the hospital, but a growing number of parents are opting against the surgery.
