Vichy leader 'widened anti-Jewish law' - Israel Jewish Scene, Ynetnews

   Israel News

Israel News
World News
Israel Opinion
Israel Business
Israel Culture
Israel Travel

Philippe Petain Photo: Getty Images Bank
Philippe Petain Photo: Getty Images Bank
Original document Photo: AFP
Original document Photo: AFP

Vichy leader 'widened anti-Jewish law'

French Nazi hunter announces discovery of original document establishing WWII restrictions for Jews showing that Philippe Petain made stringent measures even harsher

Published: 10.04.10, 08:48 / Israel Jewish Scene

A French Nazi hunter announced on Sunday the discovery of the original document establishing WWII restrictions for Jews showing that Vichy leader Philippe Petain made stringent measures even harsher.


"The discovery of this plan is fundamental. This document establishes Petain's decisive role in drawing up this position in the most aggressive way, revealing (Petain's) deep anti-Semitism," Serge Klarsfeld told AFP.


Petain, a military hero in World War I, became head of the rump state based at Vichy in central France which collaborated with the German Nazi occupiers following defeat in World War II.


The penciled-in changes to the document, from October 1940, are a "profound alteration" of the document's nature, Klarsfeld said.


While the original set out to exclude "descendants of Jews born French or naturalized before 1860", Petain crossed out this reference, thus applying the measures to all Jews in France.


The scope of Jews' exclusion is considerably widened, with the minority being barred from jobs in teaching and the judiciary as well as prevented from standing for elected office.


"The main argument of Petain's defenders was to say that he protected French Jews. This argument has now fallen," he said.


The document came to light after an anonymous donor handed it in to the Holocaust Memorial in Paris, Klarsfeld said.


Klarsfeld and his son Arno, also a lawyer, compared the script to known examples of the wartime leader's handwriting and there is "no doubt" that the annotations are his, he said.


After Germany's defeat Petain was tried by the provisional French government of General Charles de Gaulle, who commuted his death sentence to life imprisonment, and he died in 1951.


There was previously only one testimony concerning Petain's anti-Semitism, from Vichy foreign minister Paul Baudouin.


'Desire to turn Jews into scapegoats'

In a 1946 book, Baudouin wrote that during the October 1, 1940 cabinet meeting, the government spent two hours examining "the status of the Israelites. It was the marshal (Petain) who was the most severe. He insisted notably that there should be no Jews in the judiciary or education."


"Baudouin's testimony was very clear but doubt could be cast on it. Now, we have definite proof that the Jews' status was the personal will of marshal Petain," said Klarsfeld.


Petain wanted "to show that France deserved to be at the forefront of the new European order. There was also the desire to turn the Jews into scapegoats for the defeat" of France by the Nazis, said Klarsfeld.


"The status of Jews was a specifically French measure, spontaneous. The Germans didn't ask Vichy France to take this measure. But there was competition between French and German anti-Semitism.


Nevertheless, of all Nazi-occupied countries, France was the one where "the Jewish community suffered the least tragic harm," said Klarsfeld.


Around three-quarters of the Jewish population survived, or around 240,000 out of 320,000.


"That's not thanks to France but to the French, thanks to all the courageous people who helped the Jews all over the place," he said.



commentcomment   PrintPrint  Send to friendSend to friend   
Tag with Bookmark to

11 Talkbacks for this article    See all talkbacks
Please wait for the talkbacks to load


RSS RSS | About | Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Terms of use | Advertise with us | Site Map

Site developed by  YIT Advanced Technology Solutions