Critics pan 'Gandhi to Hitler' film - Israel Culture, Ynetnews

   Israel News

Israel News
World News
Israel Opinion
Israel Business
Israel Culture
Israel Travel
Controversial Movie

Hitler. 'We just hope this movie depicts him as he was' Photo: Getty Imagebank
Hitler. 'We just hope this movie depicts him as he was' Photo: Getty Imagebank
Gandhi. Message of peace Photo: Getty Images
Gandhi. Message of peace Photo: Getty Images

Critics pan 'Gandhi to Hitler' film

Even before its release, new Bollywood film raised fears among Jewish groups that it would trivialize Nazi dictator

Published: 08.01.11, 07:39 / Israel Culture

Indian critics on Friday panned a new Bollywood film about Adolf Hitler, which before its release had raised fears among Jewish groups that it would trivialize the Nazi dictator.


"Gandhi to Hitler" – renamed from earlier title "Dear Friend Hitler" – was released in cinemas on Friday and was inspired by two letters that the Indian independence leader wrote to Hitler urging him to abandon violence.


No Joke
'Spielberg fired Fox over Hitler remarks' / Ynet
Director Michael Bay sheds light on last year's dismissal of actress Megan Fox from set of 'Transformers 3': Film producer wanted her fired after she compared Bay to Nazi dictator
Full story

Early critiques on Internet film sites were far from favorable.


"The intentions are lofty enough but 'Gandhi to Hitler' has the feel of a Z-grade quickie destined to be quickly consigned to the dustbins of movie history," wrote Saibal Chatterjee on the web site.


Taran Adarsh, one of Bollywood's leading film critics and analysts, agreed, calling the film in his review on "an amateur attempt that leaves zilch impact".


Both critics said the choice of Indian actors to play all the lead and supporting roles, from Hitler (Ranghuvir Yadav) and Eva Braun (former Miss World Neha Dhupia) to Russian and French soldiers, was unconvincing.


Veteran actor Anupam Kher had been due to play the lead role, but he pulled out last June after protests from India's small Jewish community and campaigners abroad.


'Not out to glorify any character'

Producer Anil Sharma insisted in February this year that they were "not out to glorify any character. We are just telling a lost chapter of Indian independence history".


Excerpts of the film were shown at the Berlin film festival, prompting comparisons to "Downfall", the Oscar-nominated 2004 film starring Bruno Ganz.


The Hollywood Reporter in May called the film "uber-awful" after it was shown in Cannes, comparing it to the fictional musical "Springtime for Hitler" in Mel Brooks' 1968 spoof "The Producers".


David Goldfarb, a spokesman for the Israeli Embassy in New Delhi, told AFP this week that they were reserving judgment about the film until its release.

"We just hope that this movie will depict him (Hitler) as he was," he said.


Fears about glorifying the dictator seemed unlikely, as Chatterjee called "Gandhi to Hitler" a "spectacularly daft" account of the last months of Hitler's life, "utterly silly and unintentionally funny".


Adarsh said Gandhi's message of peace – interspersed in the film with shots of Hitler in his bunker – was particularly relevant in the modern era and praised the film's cinematography.


But he added: "The execution of the subject is so amateurish that it leaves you distraught... On the whole 'Gandhi to Hitler' fails to connect."



commentcomment   PrintPrint  Send to friendSend to friend   
Tag with Bookmark to

8 Talkbacks for this article    See all talkbacks
Please wait for the talkbacks to load


RSS RSS | About | Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Terms of use | Advertise with us | Site Map

Site developed by  YIT Advanced Technology Solutions