Israeliness may be the answer
Op-ed: Israeli-US community may be new avenue for secular Jews to connect to their Jewish identity
The recent Pew survey of American Jews
caused a fluster in the organized Jewish community.
In major metro areas across the United States such as Los Angeles, New York, Miami and Boston, Israeli-American organizations are popping up and growing in popularity. Programs for families, young adults and children alike, centered on Israeli culture and Jewish identity have swelling appeal.
The survey raises a number of questions about the efficacy of Jewish institutions, leaving professionals and donors alike in a position of uncertainty regarding their investments in the Jewish future. But while traditional American Jewish organizations regroup and rethink, a growing movement in the community remains largely overlooked.
Jewish Identity
Eric Schorr
Op-ed: If young American Jews had rabbi or community to reach out to them, they would be drawn back into Judaism
Participation in these Israeli-American organizations is increasing rapidly, and not only among Israeli expats and their children. In greater numbers, American Jews join in on Israeli programs related to Hebrew language, Jewish education, and creating connectedness to Israel through the arts, music, literature, and tradition.
The American way of practicing Judaism is largely based on attending synagogues and affiliating with religious congregations across the denominations. What it does not offer are substantial alternatives for Jewish involvement in a secular way. Within this reality, the phenomenon of growing Israeli communal life in the United States offers a new model for American secular Jews to express their Judaism without needing to belong to a synagogue or religious institution.
Accessible organized cultural Judaism
In Los Angeles, the Israeli American Council (IAC) reached over 50,000 members of the Israeli-American community in the area last year with its Israeli-tailored programming. The organization’s flagship event, the Celebrate Israel festival – now the largest Jewish festival in North America – turned out about 15,000 people, half Israeli-Americans and half American Jews.Other Israeli-style holiday festivals with focus on family activities, Israeli performances, and Israeli or Jewish customs rather than religious observance attract thousands and reflect a similar demographic split.
The trend continues through the young professional program BINA, targeting the age group of American Jews who are least connected to Judaism according to the Pew report. The IAC’s success, in fact, led to its recent expansion across the United States, announced at a Rosh Hashana reception just last month.
American Jews in New York have also recently been showing a growing interest in Israeli educational programs, such as “Israeliness” at the 92nd Street Y, among others.
Upon a closer look, perhaps these developing programs, which are almost entirely secular in nature, are the new avenue for secular American Jews to connect to their Jewish identity.
The Pew results revealed that 70% of American Jews feel very attached or somewhat attached to Israel, and more than 60% believe that Judaism is about culture, ancestry and identity. What better environment to cultivate those feelings and transform them into strong connectedness to one’s Jewish roots than among secular Israelis.
Although Israelis living in the United States may have left the Jewish nation state, many maintain their deep love of Israel. You might even say they do so religiously. Many do everything they can to ensure their children will inherit their intense love for Israel though Hebrew culture, Jewish knowledge, and political awareness.
As Israeli expats strive to instill a secular Israeli identity in the next generation, many American Jews find themselves relating to the approach and spirit and jump on the bandwagon. Perhaps it is the Israeliness rather than the Jewishness of this community that attracts the at-risk American Jewish demographic, making organized cultural Judaism accessible in a new and relevant way.
American Jewish leaders have responded to the Pew survey with a number of calls, including for a rejuvenated core which is literate in Hebrew, investment in Jewish culture, and alternative venues for Jewish identity.
Well, look no further. The Israeli-American community may just be the answer.
Miri Belsky is the COO of the Israeli American Council (IAC)
