Channels

Photo: Alex Kolomoisky
Minister Litzman
Photo: Alex Kolomoisky
Ultra-Orthodox minister blocks ‘Muezzin Bill’
As Arab MKs plan to protest a bill aiming to stop muezzin calls that are reported to be a public nuisance, Health Minister Yakov Litzman (United Torah Judaism) files an appeal to the Ministerial Committee for Legislation to prevent a preliminary vote in the Knesset, sending the bill back to the government for review; Litzman’s appeal is motivated not by concern for Muslim sensitivity, but over concern that the bill might bring prevent the Shabbat sirens from being played.

The “Muezzin Bill,” which aims to prevent mosques from using loudspeakers to announce prayer times, is raising a great deal of opposition, with Arab MKs and activists protesting Tuesday in the Arab city of Sakhnin and planning additional protests on Wednesday in Jaffa and the Arab city of Baqa al-Gharbiyye.

 

 

A surprising bit of opposition, though, has emerged from among the ultra-Orthodox community, with Health Minister Yakov Litzman filing an appeal on Tuesday to prevent the Knesset from voting on the Muezzin Bill, thereby sending it back to the government for further review. This will also force Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who has already voiced his support of the bill, to weigh in on the matter.

 

Health Minister Yakov Litzman (Photo: Alex Kolomoisky)
Health Minister Yakov Litzman (Photo: Alex Kolomoisky)

 

In his appeal, Litzman referred to the similarities between the muezzin calls and the call announcing the beginning of Shabbat. “For thousands of years, different instruments have been used for this purpose, including the shofar and trumpet. With the advancement of technology, loudspeakers are now used to announce the beginning of Shabbat while respecting the allowed volume and in accordance to the law.”

 

The appeal continued by saying, “The bill in its current phrasing and following the discussions that it will bring on may harm the status quo, and so in accordance to governmental protocol, this appeal is hereby submitted for further review.”

 

Prtestors in Sakhnin opposing te bill
Prtestors in Sakhnin opposing te bill

 

While Litzman’s concern is mainly over breaking the status quo, the bill has angered both Arab MKs, Arab activists and the country of Jordan. The Jordanian Head of Al-Aqsa Mosque Affairs and the Ministry of Religious Endowments, Abdullah Al Awadi, expressed his objection by saying, “In accordance with international law, the occupier cannot make any historic changes in the city that it occupies and it is required to leave things as they are,” he continued. “This proves that any Israeli decision on Jerusalem is null and void.”

 

MK Hanin Zoabi (Joint List) objected to the bill, as well. “This is a law against Palestinian presence in our homeland. It isn’t the noise that is harmful, but the outspoken presence of the Arab language that emphasizes the place’s identity, along with a certain level of controlling the space. It is a fight over it and control of it. If the will pass, we won’t respect it. We won’t lower our voice in our own space.”

 

MK Hanin Zoabi (Photo: Reuters)
MK Hanin Zoabi (Photo: Reuters)

 

Another MK to raise his voice was Jamal Zahalka (Joint List), who targeted Netanyahu in his objection. “Netanyahu has shown clear signs of chronic Islamophobia and needs immediate help, because his episodes are beginning to become dangerously combustible.” He added that “This isn’t Europe. This is where the muezzin has been making his voice heard for over a thousand years, and where Muslims will go on living … Whomever can’t stand the sound of the muezzin is welcome to go back to where they won’t hear such sounds.”

 

The Palestinian Authority also criticized the bill. Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas’s office warned against the ramifications of voting the bill into law and threatened to turn to the UN Security Council and other international organizations if this were to happen.

 

 new comment
See all talkbacks "Ultra-Orthodox minister blocks ‘Muezzin Bill’"
Warning:
This will delete your current comment