Channels
Photo: Gabi Menashe
Shulamit Aloni
Photo: Gabi Menashe
PR Photo
Avraham Ravitz
PR Photo

Where's the education?

What values can be found in Israeli schools? Who educates to morality and Judaism and who develops curiosity among the kids?

Shulamit Aloni Avraham Ravitz 

Shulamit Aloni
Another school year is under way, and much is new: A new government and a new education minister, who is educated and highly qualified for her new post.

 

She certainly deserves well wishes and encouragement, but in order to promote education and turn schools into places that are good for students she needs a prime minister that believes in the importance of education today and for the future.

 

She also needs a finance minister who realizes that investing in education is more important than additional sorties by jet fighters that target suspects (there's no evidence against them and no trial, and those wanted suspects are killed along with whole families and passersby – at a cost of thousands of dollars.)

 

During my tenure as education minister, my government's orientation was for dialogue and breakthroughs for peace. The prime minister and finance minister were partners to the path of "Israel believes in education" and the education budget grew by 70 percent in real terms (when it comes to dry figures it doubled itself, but we had inflation back then.)

 

Money won't solve everything

One of the important aspects is boosting the standing of teachers in their own eyes and in the eyes of their students. But the money won't solve everything. Teacher associations should invest effort, time and training not only in teachers' budgetary and personal needs, but also boost the level of teaching.

 

It is important that the teacher's lounge become a lounge of studying, with teachers getting further training and developing empathy to the school, to teaching, and to the students. Despite the crowded classrooms, teachers who love the subject they teach will have their students' attention.

 

Teachers who get students to participate and assign them tasks related to the studies will ensure that both students and teachers will be satisfied. It is so easy today to task a student with preparing a lecture on a section of a history lesson, be it the American or French revolution, and perhaps also the Human Rights Convention, or hold a discussion about the "Four Mothers" movement or about the story of Isaac and Rebecca.

 

There's no subject area where students cannot take part in preparing material for class: Herzl, Bialik, Ben Gurion, and even Golda and the Yom Kippur War. Curiosity can be aroused even in a classroom of 40 students, as long as teachers love and respect the profession.

 

As to the crowded classrooms, it's a disgrace that the small classes in ultra-Orthodox and religious schools enjoy the same resources as the crowded ones. The time has come to establish a per-student norm. Today, a classroom of 17 students enjoys the same services, number of hours, and number of teachers as a 40-student classroom. This arrangement may be good for coalition purposes, but it's not very educational.

 

Values cannot be taught through preaching

And another note: It's impossible to teach values through special classes and preaching. Values are taught through general teaching, general discussion, and summary of the discussion.

 

Here's a small example: From young age it's possible to teach responsibility while provide the students with a sense of self-worth. There, even at a young age bible is taught starting from Genesis.

 

Question: Why was Adam banished from the Garden of Eden? Answer: Because he ate from the Tree of Knowledge…well, not exactly. For disobeying that order they were already punished: "By the sweat of your face you will eat bread, you will bear sons in sorrow…"

 

We should know that one is not punished twice for the same offence. And there, in Genesis 3:22 we learn: "And God said, 'The man has now become like one of us, knowing good and evil. He must not be allowed to reach out his hand and take also from the tree of life and eat, and live forever.'"

 

That's the answer to the banishment from the Garden of Eden. Man, like God, distinguishes between good and bad.

 

Man knows to choose between what is right and what is not, and therefore is responsible for his actions. All of us, each one of us, parents, students, teachers, the principal, the education minister, the prime minister, army chief, and even president, we all know what is allowed and what is disallowed, what is right and what isn't.

 

Therefore we must remember this: We indeed enjoy the freedom of choice, but we're responsible for our choices, because all of us, by virtue of being human beings, possess the human characteristic of distinguishing between bad and good.

 

"By virtue of being human beings" – the sages address this as follows: We're all decedents of Adam, and therefore none of us can say: My ancestry is grander than yours. Therefore, we must also ensure equality between all people. And, by the way, when we talk about people we mean both Adam and Eve, man and woman. "He created them male and female, and blessed them, and called their name 'Adam,' in the day when they were created." (Genesis 5:2)

 

This is only one example of teaching values – while learning – both about responsibility and equality as well as about the self-worth of the student and teacher.

 

Shulamit Aloni is the former Education and Culture Minister

 

חזור למעלה
Avraham Ravitz

Education is not only about relaying technocratic information. The basis of education is personal example by the teacher and educator that manifests itself in aspects such as dress, expression ability, and devotion to the students.

 

A teacher should be etched in the student's memory as an example of a positive personality. To my regret, the education system in the past dozens of years has turned, at best, into an enterprise providing students with information on different subjects.

 

Another thing that needs to be fixed: Education must teach humane, moral values, with an emphasis on giving to the other, both the individual and society. Today, to our regret, educational institutions are a hotbed for raising egotistical people who are only concerned about personal accomplishments for their own sake.

 

Another issue where we're lacking: Our educational facilities should display a positive attitude to Judaism, history, and the messages conveyed by our religion through generations. The current ignorance displayed by the products of our education is stunning in terms of the basic lack of knowledge exhibited by students.

 

Basic questions

Our society today suffers from basic questions such as our ties to our country and people, and the question is: Why? In my view, we must urgently deepen, through our educational system, the ties to the people and its country, the land of the Bible – the Promised Land.

 

We must end the "war" of the individual and society against Judaism and those who carry its banners, as it created a huge gulf between Israeli society's various parts. At the same time, religious education should show understanding to the surrounding problems and issues faced by society.

 

At this time I would like to convey two important messages to State authorities and to the Education Ministry.

 

A. Finally end the open and hidden discrimination against ultra-Orthodox education that manifests itself through educational facilities and regular budgets. Respect the parents' desire to provide their children with Torah and religious education as was done in previous generation.

 

B. I plead, through logic, to at least postpone the implementation of the controversial Dovrat education reform plan. Many view it as doomed for failure. This year isn't the year where we can allow ourselves to deal with experiments in humans, and certainly not in students. The hundreds of millions to be saved from postponing the implementation should be transferred to child-related budgets. A hungry child cannot learn. A child without shoes finds it difficult to think. Each period has its own priority order.

 

Knesset Member Avraham Ravitz (United Torah Judaism) is the former Deputy Minister of Education

 

חזור למעלה

פרסום ראשון: 09.03.06, 20:07
 new comment
Warning:
This will delete your current comment