Committee for the Appointment of Qadis casting their vote

Muslim clerics spurn first female appointment as qadi

Deputy head of the northern branch of the Islamic Movement in Israel attacks decision made by Knesset committee headed by Justice Minister Shaked to appoint a woman as judge dealing with Islamic family law; ‘Committee has no right to interfere in our religious affairs.’

Arab clerics attacked the historic appointment of Attorney Han Khatib, a Muslim woman, to the position of qadi—a judge dealing with Islamic family law in Sharia Court. 



The decision was announced Tuesday by the Committee for the Appointment of Qadis, headed by Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked (Bayit Yehudi).


Detractors of the decision urged Minister Shaked not to "intervene in Islamic matters," arguing that "Islam does not allow a woman to be qadi."


Committee for the Appointment of Qadis casting their vote
Committee for the Appointment of Qadis casting their vote


Khatib is a resident of the Arab city of Tamra in the Lower Galilee. If sworn in, she will be the first Israeli woman to serve in this post. She holds an MA in Law and specialized in family law and Sharia law. She is also a certified mediator.


Deputy Head of the Northern Branch of the Islamic Movement in Israel, Sheikh Kamal Khatib—unrelated to the new quadi—attacked the decision by saying: "I smell a political deal here in the Sharia Court system. I am not a mufti, but the opinion in Islamic Sharia law is that a woman cannot be appointed as qadi, for very convincing reasons.


"I wonder who the people were on the appointment committee, since some of them have nothing to do with the religion of Islam and have no right to interfere in our religious affairs, and whose connection to Islamic law is like my connection with space science."


While adding that he did not personally know the newly-appointed  qadi, he said that he respected any person who contributes to society.


Attorney Han Khatib
Attorney Han Khatib


"The committee members have to respect themselves and the others. They want to appear as supporting the advancement of women, but that's not the truth. The Israeli side wants to show that it respects Islam, but the truth is that those who support the end of the muezzin's call do not respect Islam, and neither do those who desecrate the Al-Aqsa Mosque."


The Sheikh then went on to accuse Minister Shaked and Minister Miri Regev of "supported a proposal to fine anyone who calls out 'Allah Akbar' at the Al-Aqsa Mosque, so how can she now claim to respect Islam?"


The Southern Branch of the Islamic Movement, on the other hand, announced its support for the appointment, and wished the new qadi success in her new position.


Sheikh Kamal Khatib
Sheikh Kamal Khatib


MK Issawi Frej (Meretz), a member of the committee that appointed Khatib, defended the decision. "The committee included the head of the Sharia Court, Qadi Abd al-Hakim Samara, Qadi and Attorney Iyad Zahalka, and other legal experts who accompanied the committee during the appointment process and examined all the steps in the most professional manner possible," Frej said. 


"I personally heard all the opinions that supported the appointment of the first woman to the role of qadi, and I also heard its opponents. However, Muslim countries like Jordan, Indonesia and Egypt have already allowed the appointment of women to the role of qadi."


He added that he was convinced "that this is a historic step, and that our religion can be proud of it. I believe and am convinced that a woman should hold a position within society and that she must be supported. We need to respect the opinions of others as well as majority decisions."


פרסום ראשון: 04.27.17, 09:33
 new comment
This will delete your current comment