Channels

Photo: AFP
Sadat, Begin and Carter
Photo: AFP

40 years of peace with Israel - an Egyptian perspective

The anniversary of the US-brokered accord stirs complex emotions in the largest country in the Arab world, where some highlight the economic benefits the agreement brought, while others cannot see the deal lasting

CAIRO - Just days before the 40th anniversary of the March 26, 1979 peace treaty between Egypt and Israel, Egyptian lawmakers lashed out at Washington for new “assaults on the rights of the Arab world.”

 

 

In a statement issued by Egypt’s parliament, legislators slammed US President Donald Trump’s imminent recognition of Israeli sovereignty over the Golan Heights – captured from Syria during the 1967 Six-Day War – and the State Department’s u-turn on a five decades of policy of referring to the West Bank as “occupied” territory.

 

US President Jimmy Carter congratulates Egyptian President Anwar al-Sadat and Israeli Premier Menachem Begin after signing the historic US-sponsored peace treaty between Israel and Egypt. (Photo: Getty Images)
US President Jimmy Carter congratulates Egyptian President Anwar al-Sadat and Israeli Premier Menachem Begin after signing the historic US-sponsored peace treaty between Israel and Egypt. (Photo: Getty Images)

 

“All tragedies begin in the field of language,” wrote Yousef Al-Qa’id, a renowned Egyptian novelist and Nasserist parliamentarian, in a blog post ahead of the statement’s release.

 

“The word normalization means…there was an existing relationship that then (changed),” Qa’id said.

 

“So when (Egypt’s then-president Anwar) Sadat decided to speak in the (Knesset in 1979), and the flags of the Zionist enemy were raised in Cairo, all of us were consigned to captivity of a normalizationwith the deadly terrorist, (Israel’s then-prime minister Menachem) Begin, whose hands were stained with the blood of the Palestinians.”

 

Menachem Begin and Anwar Sadat at the Knesset on November 20, 1977  (Photo: Getty Images)
Menachem Begin and Anwar Sadat at the Knesset on November 20, 1977 (Photo: Getty Images)

 

The Egypt-Israeli peace accord included billions of dollars in American economic and security assistance for both countries, and their defense ministries reap benefits from the agreement. Yet the accompanying 1978 “Framework for Peace in the Middle East,” which included stipulations for Palestinian self-rule, remains unfulfilled, thus fueling the rage of Egyptians like Qa’id.

 

To Alexandria researcher and writer Amin El-Mahdy, the legacy of the 1979 pact is a twisted reality in which neither Egyptians nor Israelis fully believe in its long-term viability.

 

“For 30 years, Egyptians paid the price of war with Israel, and for the last 40 have suffered the cost of a militarized peace,” says Mahdy.

 

“This all fits the racist orientation of the Israeli right – while in Egypt, merely talking about coexistence and cooperation with the Israeli people or daring to ask for a visa to visit Tel Aviv became a type of social crime that leads to… the risk of assassination.”

 

 

Benjamin Netanyahu and Egyptian President Sisi at the UN General Assembly in Sept. 2018
Benjamin Netanyahu and Egyptian President Sisi at the UN General Assembly in Sept. 2018

 

The researcher/writer sees a of connection between what he claims is the way Israel has prolonged the conflict with its insistence on maintaining control over the Palestinians and that the Egyptian military dominate in matters of civil society.

 

“Begin preferred Israeli settlements to peace but was outflanked by the victorious generals Yigael Yadin and Ezer Weizman, plus the 1,500 (Israeli) army officers who signed a statement calling for peace,” Mahdy said.

 

“On the other hand, while Sadat believed peace was the key to Egypt’s progress, he headed a feudal military regime defeated in battle that viewed negotiations with suspicion. Internally, anti-Semitism and a rejection of peace are still the official policy fed to the Egyptian people,” he said.

 

Mahdy noted Sadat’s 1981 assassination during a military parade, saying, “thus, the peace process went sideways and the security and economic relations between the two states are purely a military arrangement.”

 

Abdel al-Fattah el-Sisi, Egypt’s current leader, has another view of the peace agreement. Since assuming power in 2014, he has stated on multiple occasions that resolving the Palestinian issue would eliminate one of the most important factors contributing to Middle East instability and one of the primary justifications for acts of extremism and terrorism.

 

He also said that a Palestinian-Israeli deal would allow for a “warmer peace” between Egypt and the Jewish state.

 

Sisi’s foreign minister, Sameh Shukri, departed this week for talks in Washington as Egypt and the wider Arab world become increasingly anxious about the contours of Trump’s “deal of the century,” an Israeli-Palestinian peace plan expected to be released soon after Israel’s April 9 elections.

 

 

Israel captured the Gaza Strip from Egypt in 1967 (Photo: AFP)
Israel captured the Gaza Strip from Egypt in 1967 (Photo: AFP)

 

“I am waiting like the rest of us to see if it (comprises) political and economic plans… that aim to reach a settlement whereby there can be a Palestinian state along the (1967 borders, which was) accepted by former prime minister (Ehud) Olmert,” Ahmed Aboul Gheit, secretary-general of the Arab League, tells The Media Line.

 

“If we see a Palestinian state living side-by-side with Israel and a package that would generate enough activity and vitality in the Palestinian economy, we’ll (consider) it,” he says. “But if it is limited to only an economic blanket for the Palestinians trying to cover the (absence) of a political settlement…it won’t work.”

 

One “economic blanket” that has kept the peace from evaporating was the establishment of Qualifying Industrial Zones (QIZ) by US Congress in 1996. Since taking effect in February 2005, they have allowed products jointly manufactured by Egypt and Israel duty-free entry into the US.

 

The Taba Crossing between Israel and Egypt's Sinai Peninsula (Photo: EPA)
The Taba Crossing between Israel and Egypt's Sinai Peninsula (Photo: EPA)

  

QIZ products make up 46 percent of Egypt’s total exports to the US, and 52% of non-oil exports.

 

Egypt’s exports from QIZ rose by 17%, to $878 million, in 2018, up from $751 million in 2017, according to Egyptian Trade Ministry sources.

 

“QIZ is an excellent step toward consolidating the ideas of peace and building coexistence in the region,” says Cairo entrepreneur Ramy Kamil. “Land is allocated to me in the industrial zone in Beni Suef Governorate, and I am hoping to build a factory for ready-made clothes that can directly employ 500 full-time workers and about 600 seasonal employees.”

 

Kamil notes that this opens up the US market.

 

“It’s a great gain for Egypt," he says. "Exports within this framework reached nearly $1 billion and provided job opportunities for thousands of Egyptian workers who became more aware that the gains of peace are greater than the gains of wars and conflict.”

 

Written by Mina Nader. Reprinted with permission from The Media Line

 


פרסום ראשון: 03.30.19, 22:35
 new comment
See all talkbacks "40 years of peace with Israel - an Egyptian perspective"
Warning:
This will delete your current comment