Herzog urges government to postpone judicial reforms

President says the Supreme Court safeguards Israel and its society; must better reflect Israeli diversity and can be reformed; cautions Israel embroiled not in a political dispute but in possible constitutional collapes

President Issac Herzog said the planned overhaul of the judicial system proposed by the government is detrimental to the democratic foundations of Israel and must be postponed until a compromise is found.
  • Follow Ynetnews on Facebook and Twitter

  • In a speech addressing the nation on Sunday, the president urged dialogue to reach broad agreements between the proponents and opponents of the legislation to prevent fracture in the Israeli society that could lead to violence.
    2 View gallery
    נשיא המדינה יצחק הרצוג
    נשיא המדינה יצחק הרצוג
    President Issac Herzog
    (Photo: GPO)
    "This is not a political dispute," Herzog said. "We are on the verge of a constitutional and social collapse."
    The president asked that the scheduled votes in the Knesset Constitution, Law, Justice committee - scheduled for Monday - be postponed until dialogue can begin to reach a broad consensus on the legislation.
    Herzog said the basic premise is that the Knesset is the elected legislative body and that the government has the right to advance policies, but there must be checks and balances, adding that the Supreme Court safeguards Israel and its society.
    "Change can be legitimate," he said. "The courts can better represent the spectrum of Israeli society."
    2 View gallery
    המפגינים חוסמים את נתיבי איילון
    המפגינים חוסמים את נתיבי איילון
    Mass demonstration against proposed government legislation in Tel Aviv on Saturday
    (Photo: Reuters)
    Herzog said the Knesset must first pass a Basic Law on legislation that would outline the relations between the Knesset and the courts, but after a broad agreement is reached.
    He said the courts are suffering from a shortage of judges and need additional personnel to sit on the bench and expedite justice.
    The president said judges must be elected by a committee in which neither the courts nor politicians have a majority of votes. The courts also must include mutually agreed representatives of the public to be chosen by the justice minister and chief justice.
    "If one side is victorious, we will all be defeated," he said.
    Chairman of the Knesset Constitution, Law Justice Committee Simcha Rothman of the Religious Zionist party, rejected the appeal from Herzog to postpone the vote on the bills. "The demand to delay legislation is an opposition view," he said. "Stopping the legislation is an attempt to undermine the government."
    U.S. Ambassador to Israel Tom Nides praised the president's speech. "Great speech tonight by a great leader. Thank you, President @Isaac_Herzog," he wrote on Twitter.
    The commenter agrees to the privacy policy of Ynet News and agrees not to submit comments that violate the terms of use, including incitement, libel and expressions that exceed the accepted norms of freedom of speech.