הפיגוע במסעדת סבארו
Suicide bombing at a Jerusalem cafe during the Second Intifada
Photo: Getty Images
Palestinian student at Al-Quds University Moayad Afaneh, 22, poses for a picture during an interview with AFP by the wall separating East Jerusalem from the Palestinian village of Abu Dis

20 years after Second Intifada, Palestinians look toward bleak future

Two decades after the events of September 28, 2000, the older generation involved in the fighting back then believes the Third Intifada is a matter of time, while young people's main concerns involve either finding a job or moving overseas

AFP |
Published: 09.28.20 , 19:11
Two decades on from the Second Intifada, Palestinians who grew up in the shadow of the uprising find themselves surrounded by physical and political barriers with little hope for the future.
  • Follow Ynetnews on Facebook and Twitter


  • In Jenin refugee camp, in the north of the West Bank, the walls are plastered with posters showing young Palestinian men wearing keffiyeh scarfs around their necks and clutching AK-47 assault rifles.
    Palestinian student at Al-Quds University Moayad Afaneh, 22, poses for a picture during an interview with AFP by the wall separating East Jerusalem from the Palestinian village of Abu Dis Palestinian student at Al-Quds University Moayad Afaneh, 22, poses for a picture during an interview with AFP by the wall separating East Jerusalem from the Palestinian village of Abu Dis
    Palestinian student at Al-Quds University Moayad Afaneh, 22, poses for a picture during an interview with AFP by the wall separating East Jerusalem from the Palestinian village of Abu Dis
    (Photo: AFP)
    Whether killed by Israeli forces or jailed, their images have faded over the years.
    "When I walk through the camp, I try to reconcile my memory with what I see today," said Nidal Naghnaghyeh Turkeman, 48, who spent 17 years in prison for his role in the uprising.
    Nidal fought in the ranks of the main Palestinian faction Fatah in the First Intifada (1987 to 1993) which preceded a brief optimistic period when the Oslo peace accords brought hope of a lasting solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
    But by the turn of the century disillusionment had set in and the second intifada broke out after right-wing Israeli opposition leader Ariel Sharon visited the Al-Aqsa mosque compound in east Jerusalem on September 28, 2000.
    The move was seen as a provocation by Palestinians and violent clashes between them and Israeli forces followed.
    הפיגוע במסעדת סבארוהפיגוע במסעדת סבארו
    Suicide bombing at a Jerusalem cafe during the Second Intifada
    (Photo: Getty Images)
    The Second Intifada lasted five years, during which attacks were carried out in Israel, the Gaza Strip and the West Bank.
    In response Israel reoccupied much of the West Bank and began building a separation barrier between the two communities that in places cuts deep into occupied territory.
    Jenin refugee camp was caught up in the violence and in 2002 was besieged by Israeli forces for more than a month.
    Turkeman, who lost two brothers in the fighting, was jailed for his role in an attack shortly after the siege which killed six Israeli civilians.
    Emigration or fighting
    While reminders of the uprising can be seen on the streets of Jenin, such as a former fighter selling grapes in a wheelchair, daily life has changed significantly over the past two decades.
    Israel built the West Bank security barrier - which Palestinians call an apartheid wall separating them from Jerusalem - saying it was necessary to prevent attacks.
    חיילים בפאתי רמאללה במבצע חומת מגןחיילים בפאתי רמאללה במבצע חומת מגן
    IDF troops begin operation Protective Shield in West Bank in 2002 after surge in bombings
    (Photo: Getty Images)
    In December 2017, U.S. President Donald Trump recognized Jerusalem as Israel's capital, going against international consensus that the city's status can only be defined as part of a peace accord.
    Turkeman's twin daughters, Yara and Sara, were born just weeks before the siege and saw little of their father growing up.
    "At the start we rejected him. We couldn't find a place for him in our hearts," said Sara, an 18-year-old studying IT at university.
    Despite having no memories of the Second Intifada, the twins say their father is still viewed as a hero by young Palestinians in Jenin.
     Palestinian militants during the Second Intifada  Palestinian militants during the Second Intifada
    Palestinian militants during the Second Intifada
    "Today, we are still in the intifada, there are attacks every day, people wounded and nothing has been solved," said Sara, her sister nodding her head in agreement. "There is no future here, the only two options are immigration or fighting."
    Loss of hope
    The Israeli military controls 60 percent of the West Bank and many Palestinians lament how the occupation has been normalized over the decades following the unrealized Oslo accords.
    The Palestinian leadership has slammed agreements Israel signed with the United Arab Emirates and Bahrain at a September 15 White House ceremony hosted by Trump.
    But their calls for protest have largely fallen flat with young Palestinians who, according to analyst Ghassan Khatib, "feel really isolated and deprived" of any role in politics.
    שרידי האוטובוסשרידי האוטובוס
    Suicide bombing on Egged's Bus Line 823 during the Second Intifada
    (Photo: Elad Gershgoren )
    "There haven't been elections for 15 years and with the economic crisis... young people think more about trying to find a job," said the Palestinian expert.
    There is a marked generational gap between 60 percent of the Palestinian population who are under 30, according to United Nations data, and the leadership of 84-year-old Palestinian president Mahmud Abbas.
    "The crisis of this generation really started during the second intifada," said Khatib. "Palestinian youth began to understand that neither the peace process nor armed combat worked, this led to a loss of hope," he added.
    In the streets of Jenin, 20-year-old barber Oday says his priority is to earn money to support his family and then get married.
    "We talk more about what the Israeli army does, the (house) demolitions, attacks, those wounded," said Oday, who spends his free time playing video games.
    The Israeli army regularly demolishes Palestinian homes built without permits - which are almost impossible to obtain - or those belonging to people suspected of carrying out attacks.
    Palestinian student at Al-Quds University Aya Abu al-Amal, 18, makes her way to class along the wall separating East Jerusalem from the Palestinian village of Abu Dis Palestinian student at Al-Quds University Aya Abu al-Amal, 18, makes her way to class along the wall separating East Jerusalem from the Palestinian village of Abu Dis
    Palestinian student at Al-Quds University Aya Abu al-Amal, 18, makes her way to class along the wall separating East Jerusalem from the Palestinian village of Abu Dis
    (Photo: AFP)
    In Abu Dis, which is on the outskirts of east Jerusalem and cut off from the city centre by the barrier, fallout from the uprising looms large.
    "Life must have been better for the previous generation, because there were no walls, checkpoints, and there were job opportunities," said 18-year-old Aya.
    Studying to become a carer, Aya must pass through an Israeli checkpoint to travel from her home to the nearby Al-Quds University.
    Gazing at the high concrete wall, Muayed, a 22-year-old law student, said it represented the "biggest example" of the challenges young Palestinians face.
    We have no future
    In Gaza, the Islamist group Hamas took power and the impoverished and densely-populated coastal enclave has been under an Israeli and Egyptian blockade since 2007.
    מכליות סולר שמיועדות להפעלת תחנת החשמל ברצועת עזהמכליות סולר שמיועדות להפעלת תחנת החשמל ברצועת עזה
    Fuel being transported from Israel into Gaza
    Palestinians there are facing considerably worse conditions, with the blockade leading to perennial power cuts, a lack of clean water, and a youth unemployment rate hitting 65 percent, according to World Bank data.
    "Here, we have no future," said Saja Emad, a 20-year-old Gazan. "There's the blockade, we can't travel, Hamas and Fatah are divided, and there's no work for young people. We are frustrated and don't have hope anymore of seeing a Palestinian state in the near future."
    Since Hamas took over the enclave in 2007 after bloody clashes with Abbas's Fatah, it has fought three wars with Israel, with small-scale cross-border fighting erupting every few months and sees Palestinian militants fire barrages of rockets into Israeli territory.
    יירוט של כיפת ברזל יירוט של כיפת ברזל
    Barrages of rockets into Israeli territory from Gaza
    (Photo: Reuters)
    But while many Palestinians are focusing on just getting by, in Jenin, Turkeman believes a third "and bigger" intifada will erupt one day.
    "I'm still trying to get to know my daughters, to build bridges with them, and like me, they think that the fight must continue because they are suffering," he said.

    Talkbacks for this article 0