Hardened and hopeless, young Palestinians commit bloody attacks

Analysis: Both Israeli and Palestinian experts are at pains to seek a more nuanced understanding of what drives youthful Palestinian attackers to commit violent acts

AFP|
It is a common sight in east Jerusalem, a Palestinian area annexed by Israel following the 1967 Six-Day War, where security forces say they must be ever vigilant to thwart attacks amid a surge in violence.
  • Follow Ynetnews on Facebook and Twitter

  • In recent weeks, several bloody attacks targeting Israelis have been carried out by Palestinian teenagers armed with knives and guns.
    4 View gallery
    Israeli security forces gather at a checkpoint at the entrance to east Jerusalem's Shuafat refugee camp following a stabbing attack on February 13, 2023
    Israeli security forces gather at a checkpoint at the entrance to east Jerusalem's Shuafat refugee camp following a stabbing attack on February 13, 2023
    Israeli security forces gather at a checkpoint at the entrance to east Jerusalem's Shuafat refugee camp following a stabbing attack on February 13, 2023
    (Photo: AHMAD GHARABLI / AFP/File)
    "It is difficult to thwart the attacks by these individuals," Israeli army spokesman Ran Kochav told public broadcaster Kan, underlining the "challenge that this represents for the intelligence services".
    "It is very difficult to know what a 13-year-old boy is thinking when he decides to carry a knife and carry out an attack, without telling anyone around him."
    On January 28, amid a surge in violence in the West Bank and the day after a deadly attack outside an east Jerusalem synagogue, a 13-year-old Palestinian shot and wounded two Israelis, a father and his son.
    On February 13, a 14-year-old Palestinian boy knifed a passerby in the Old City.
    On the same day, a 13-year-old also stabbed an Israeli policeman during a security check on a bus at the entrance to East Jerusalem's Shu'afat refugee camp.
    4 View gallery
    Israeli police mourn during the funeral of a fellow officer killed in a stabbing attack carried out by a Palestinian boy in annexed east Jerusalem, in the Bedouin town of Hussniyya in northern Israel on February 14, 2023
    Israeli police mourn during the funeral of a fellow officer killed in a stabbing attack carried out by a Palestinian boy in annexed east Jerusalem, in the Bedouin town of Hussniyya in northern Israel on February 14, 2023
    Israeli police mourn during the funeral of a fellow officer killed in a stabbing attack carried out by a Palestinian boy in East Jerusalem, in the Bedouin town of Hussniyya in northern Israel on February 14, 2023
    (Photo: JACK GUEZ / AFP/File)
    After decades of bitter conflict, such youthful Palestinian attackers are routinely condemned as "murderers" or "terrorists" on one side, and celebrated as "soldiers" or, if they are killed, "martyrs" on the other.
    But experts both in Israel and the Palestinian territories are at pains to seek a more nuanced understanding of what drives them to commit such violence.

    'Trauma'

    Both of the boys accused of carrying out the attacks on February 13 were Palestinians from the Shu'afat refugee camp, a densely packed area of homes.
    The mother of one of them, Fidaa al-Zalabani, 38, recounted how she, her husband and eldest son were all questioned by police after her son was arrested for the attack.
    "They accused me of being an accomplice, of having known what my son was going to do and protecting him," she said, recalling that she was questioned for seven hours.
    "But no mother tells her son to go and stab a police officer."
    Psychiatrist Mahmoud Sehwail, based in the West Bank city of Ramallah, said that children who carry out this type of attack have often faced violence themselves.
    "Behind each of these people there is a story and trauma," said Sehwail, director of the Treatment and Rehabilitation Center, which provides psychosocial services to survivors of violence.
    Often, he said, "the ones who experience violence become violent themselves".
    Sehwail said that the root cause is the Israeli presence in the West Bank, as well as the imposition of a blockade on Gaza since 2007 after Hamas Islamists seized control of the coastal enclave.
    4 View gallery
    A member of the Israeli security forces uses tear gas to disperse Palestinians demonstrating against the demolition of houses by Israeli authorities in the Arab neighbourhood of Silwan in Israeli-annexed east Jerusalem, on March 3, 2023
    A member of the Israeli security forces uses tear gas to disperse Palestinians demonstrating against the demolition of houses by Israeli authorities in the Arab neighbourhood of Silwan in Israeli-annexed east Jerusalem, on March 3, 2023
    A member of the Israeli security forces uses tear gas to disperse Palestinians demonstrating against the demolition of houses by Israeli authorities in the Arab neighbourhood of Silwan in East Jerusalem, on March 3, 2023
    (Photo: AHMAD GHARABLI / AFP/File)
    The Palestinian psychiatrist added that "this is what makes our children hate their children. Violence will end when the occupation ends".

    'No future'

    The youths carrying out attacks come from a generation who also grew up on violent videos posted on social media, said Michael Milshtein, specialist on Palestinian affairs at the Moshe Dayan Center for Middle Eastern and African Studies at Tel Aviv University.
    "They have no future in front of them," he said, adding that they do not feel represented by the Palestinian Authority led by 87-year-old president Mahmoud Abbas, who has spent nearly two decades in power.
    Young Palestinians experience constant pressure, making them "feel helpless," said Leah Tsemel, an Israeli lawyer with several Palestinian clients.
    "They know they live under permanent occupation", Tsemel said, adding that some children worry they could be expelled from their homes and that many have witnessed their father or a brother being arrested.
    4 View gallery
    Israeli police stand guard in Jerusalem's Old City following a stabbing attack on February 13, 2023
    Israeli police stand guard in Jerusalem's Old City following a stabbing attack on February 13, 2023
    Israeli police stand guard in Jerusalem's Old City following a stabbing attack on February 13, 2023
    (Photo: RONALDO SCHEMIDT / AFP/File)
    "Parents are busy providing for the needs of their families," she said. "They do not tell their sons to go and pick up a stone and commit an attack -- they all want their children to study.
    "But children cannot accept this situation, so they take action."
    In Shu'afat, a young activist, who asked not to be named fearing arrest, condemned the ring of security posts around the camp that separates it from the Israeli settlement of Pisgaat Zeev.
    "Five minutes from here there are five parks," he said.
    "But what is there for the young people here? Nothing, there is nothing. Young people do not believe they have a future."
    Comments
    The commenter agrees to the privacy policy of Ynet News and agrees not to submit comments that violate the terms of use, including incitement, libel and expressions that exceed the accepted norms of freedom of speech.
    ""