יחיא סינוואר
Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar
Photo: AFP
Hind Khoudary, a former Amnesty activist who tipped off Hamas officials

Gaza arrests for Zoom chat with Israelis spark 'normalization' row

Former Amnesty activist Hind Khoudary tipped off Hamas officials that 6 members of the Gaza Youth Committee chatted with left-wing campaigners in Israel; now, the Palestinian street is split over fight for free speech and campaign against 'violent Israeli occupation'

AFP |
Published: 04.14.20 , 13:57
A fierce dispute has divided the Palestinian community after Gaza's rulers, Hamas, arrested six local activists for chatting by video conference with left-leaning campaigners in Israel.
  • Follow Ynetnews on Facebook and Twitter

  • Islamist group Hamas bans all communications with Israel and last week arrested the six members of the Gaza Youth Committee on charges of "treason" and "normalization" of relations with the Jewish state.
    Hind KhoudaryHind Khoudary
    Hind Khoudary, a former Amnesty activist who tipped off Hamas officials
    (Photo: YouTube)
    The arrests have sparked a fierce free-speech row that has drawn in a former Gaza-based contractor with human rights group Amnesty International who had criticized the activists online.
    In the two-hour call via video conference service Zoom - the latest in a format they have called "Skype with your enemy" - the participants had discussed their daily lives and expressed hopes for better leadership for both Israelis and Palestinians.
    Rami Aman, 36, the founder of the Gaza Youth Committee, and the five others were detained, accused of "treason", after speaking to the dozens of Israeli activists online.
    Gaza's Hamas-run Interior Ministry said that "establishing any activity or communication with the Israeli occupation under any excuse is a crime punishable by law, and is treason against our people".
     יחיא סינוואר יחיא סינוואר
    Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar
    (Photo: AFP)
    Hamas, which is considered a terrorist group by Israel and most Western states, seized control of Gaza in a 2007 near civil war.
    Since then the Jewish state has fought three devastating wars in Gaza while maintaining a crippling blockade on the coastal strip, arguing it must isolate Hamas.
    'Not a mistake'
    A key player in the row has been the former Amnesty activist Hind Khoudary, who on Facebook criticized Aman over the alleged act of "normalization" with Israel.
    Khoudary tagged several Hamas officials in the online post, ensuring Aman's Zoom call would come to their attention.
    Gaza's Interior Ministry has however denied that Khoudary's posts tipped them off to the video call.
    "It is not true what was published, saying citizens or journalists publishing posts on Facebook and social media were responsible for the arrests," ministry spokesman Iyad al-Bozm said.
    "Rami Aman and his group are under surveillance all the time by the security services.
    "Unfortunately, Rami tried to carry out activities that violate the law and the culture and customs of our people."
    Gaza city center with Hamas monumentGaza city center with Hamas monument
    Gaza city center with Hamas monument
    (Photo: Reuters)
    Khoudary said she did not regret her posts and did not oppose Aman's arrest, while stressing that she was not responsible for his detention.
    "I didn't make a mistake," she said, criticizing him over what she described as his attempt to speak on behalf of all Palestinians.
    "As a Palestinian, before I became a journalist, I am against normalization," said Khoudary.
    Amnesty confirmed that Khoudary had been a "short-term freelance contract worker" who helped document protests in Gaza last year, but said she no longer works for the organization.
    "We absolutely condemn arrests of individuals because of practising their right to peaceful expression and assembly," said Saleh Hijazi, Amnesty's deputy director for the Middle East.
    Hamas police patrol Gaza streetsHamas police patrol Gaza streets
    Hamas police patrol Gaza streets
    (Photo: EPA)
    Former Human Rights Watch official Peter Bouckaert removed Khoudary from an online group and told her she should be "ashamed" of herself.
    UN Watch, a Geneva-based organization originally set up to confront alleged anti-Semitism at the United Nations, however praised Aman as a "courageous Gaza peace activist".
    Dialogue or not?
    Khoudary herself was detained by Hamas last year for posts supporting Gaza street protests.
    Aman was briefly detained two years ago on similar charges.
    Debate has flared on social networks, with some Palestinians condemning the latest arrests and others congratulating Khoudary for working against normalization.
    Collaborating or even communicating with Israelis is controversial among Palestinians, with many seeing such dialogue as a waste of time.
    The border wall between Gaza and Israel The border wall between Gaza and Israel
    The border wall between Gaza and Israel
    (Photo: Getty Images )
    Others argue that shutting down dialogue makes a solution between the warring parties even more unlikely.
    "Palestinian for the most part reject normalizing activities because they contribute to a narrative that all that is needed is dialogue," said Yara Hawari, senior policy fellow at the Al Shabaka Palestinian think-thank.
    "In actuality what is needed before any kind of reconciliation process is an end to the continuous and structural violence - which in this case is the violent Israeli military occupation."

    Talkbacks for this article 0