תיירים ראשונים בבית לחם
Tourists in Bethlehem
People line up at the Church of the Holy Sepulcher, in the Old City of Jerusalem, March 2022

Israeli attorney takes on Tourism Ministry over Palestinian workers

After 37 tour guides from Bethlehem denied work in Israel, Raanan Carmon decided to advocate for these apolitical, talented individuals to pursue their careers despite opposition from Israeli officials citing pandemic curbs as excuse

The Media Line, Ynet |
Published: 04.08.22, 14:38
After many certified guides from the Bethlehem area of the West Bank were unable to obtain permits to guide tours across the Green Line, one attorney emerged as unlikely hero.
  • Follow Ynetnews on Facebook and Twitter

  • Raanan Carmon called the denial of work permits “plain discrimination” and “unfair," sating he was surprised to learn that after extensive training and with no criminal background, the Palestinian guides are unable to visit Jerusalem for even one day.
    4 View gallery
    People line up at the Church of the Holy Sepulcher, in the Old City of Jerusalem, March 17, 2022
    People line up at the Church of the Holy Sepulcher, in the Old City of Jerusalem, March 17, 2022
    People line up at the Church of the Holy Sepulcher, in the Old City of Jerusalem, March 2022
    (Photo: AP)
    Carmon attested that apart from the recent COVID-19 travel restrictions, Christian tourism is rapidly growing. He thinks it would be good for Christian tourists to have the opportunity to be guided by Christians and Muslims from Bethlehem, and in particular by these 37 guides, who he says are highly professional and academic.
    He interviewed all 37 guides from Bethlehem and came away impressed. They all speak at least two languages, and many speak third and fourth languages, including French, Spanish, Russian, Indonesian and German.
    Carmon said that he does not see any political angle in the guides’ fight for permits. They simply want to work and grow their careers, he said.
    4 View gallery
    תיירים ראשונים בבית לחם
    תיירים ראשונים בבית לחם
    Tourists in Bethlehem
    One of the guides, who asked to remain anonymous, explained the extensive certification process each is required to follow under the Palestinian Authority. After completing three to four years of higher education, another two years of tourism studies are required before taking the licensing test. There are only up to about 150 licensed tour guides in the general category, the source said.
    The appeal to allow the Palestinian guides to work in Israel, which was submitted to Tourism Ministry, the legal adviser to the Civil Administration, and the District Coordination and Liaison Office, is based on the 1994 Paris Protocol signed by Israel and the PLO, the source explained.
    In the Paris Protocol, officially called the Protocol on Economic Relations, the sides agreed to equal access to tourist sites for licensed guides and companies.
    4 View gallery
    Israel tourism
    Israel tourism
    Israel tourism
    (Photo: Ziv Reinstein)
    Carmon estimates that 50 Palestinian tour guides and 7,000 Israeli guides are permitted to stay with their tour groups through all areas of Israel and the Palestinian territories.
    Without the proper permit, tour guides must stay on their respective sides of the Green Line. An appeal for more than 50 permits per year for Palestinian guides was denied in June 2020 by the Tourism Ministry.
    The appeal process began months before the first COVID-19 lockdown and continued into the summer of 2020.
    The ministry responded saying: “As incoming tourism slowly returns to routine, the Tourism Ministry is working with the Israel Police and the Israel Defense Forces in order to facilitate the required permits for Palestinian licensed tour guides to guide in Israel. It is expected that this process will be completed within the near future.”
    4 View gallery
    שרת התיירות
    שרת התיירות
    Tourism minister
    (Photo: Tourism Ministry)
    In a letter to Carmon, the ministry cited the decline in tourism during the pandemic as one of the reasons for the denial. The ministry invited him to reapply when the “circumstances change.”
    Carmon believes that if the case progresses to Israel’s Supreme Court, the 37 guides will prevail.

    The story was written by Crystal Dunlap and reprinted with permission from the Media Line.
    Talkbacks for this article 0